Berliner Boersenzeitung - Hosting Britain's migrants: The view from Rwanda

EUR -
AED 4.281785
AFN 73.452334
ALL 95.429651
AMD 429.262728
ANG 2.087503
AOA 1070.299611
ARS 1646.071042
AUD 1.619085
AWG 2.098626
AZN 1.986664
BAM 1.958695
BBD 2.348401
BDT 143.127251
BGN 1.946965
BHD 0.439866
BIF 3469.728069
BMD 1.165903
BND 1.490102
BOB 8.056908
BRL 5.872776
BSD 1.165988
BTN 110.713639
BWP 15.645124
BYN 3.194922
BYR 22851.703681
BZD 2.345166
CAD 1.609005
CDF 2648.932604
CHF 0.910709
CLF 0.026367
CLP 1037.712648
CNY 7.88891
CNH 7.886595
COP 4305.843925
CRC 527.063197
CUC 1.165903
CUP 30.896436
CVE 110.615118
CZK 24.279007
DJF 207.204784
DKK 7.47393
DOP 68.019254
DZD 154.808958
EGP 61.006856
ERN 17.488549
ETB 184.21313
FJD 2.590409
FKP 0.865202
GBP 0.866681
GEL 3.113417
GGP 0.865202
GHS 13.688159
GIP 0.865202
GMD 84.532475
GNF 10236.630941
GTQ 8.894108
GYD 243.930539
HKD 9.137126
HNL 30.978502
HRK 7.532439
HTG 152.69569
HUF 353.842897
IDR 20780.651445
ILS 3.267036
IMP 0.865202
INR 110.773055
IQD 1527.333256
IRR 1575193.585016
ISK 143.359913
JEP 0.865202
JMD 183.645923
JOD 0.826672
JPY 185.738927
KES 150.879988
KGS 101.958687
KHR 4675.272437
KMF 492.011579
KPW 1049.144158
KRW 1757.506323
KWD 0.360778
KYD 0.971736
KZT 568.169776
LAK 25594.495481
LBP 104406.636357
LKR 384.788732
LRD 213.506078
LSL 18.934713
LTL 3.44261
LVL 0.705244
LYD 7.403929
MAD 10.707364
MDL 20.177824
MGA 4885.135018
MKD 61.616675
MMK 2448.448944
MNT 4174.360155
MOP 9.409465
MRU 46.636533
MUR 55.229278
MVR 17.959269
MWK 2025.174346
MXN 20.234022
MYR 4.629223
MZN 74.507092
NAD 18.934708
NGN 1599.273829
NIO 42.637521
NOK 10.78869
NPR 177.141822
NZD 1.949182
OMR 0.449196
PAB 1.166023
PEN 3.963493
PGK 5.077554
PHP 71.672781
PKR 324.762787
PLN 4.231005
PYG 7015.36898
QAR 4.245098
RON 5.251349
RSD 117.38435
RUB 82.95033
RWF 1705.133502
SAR 4.398141
SBD 9.365071
SCR 15.781711
SDG 700.129187
SEK 10.790487
SGD 1.48863
SHP 0.870465
SLE 28.685495
SLL 24448.410635
SOS 666.317977
SRD 43.337211
STD 24131.843306
STN 24.95033
SVC 10.202905
SYP 128.869732
SZL 18.934699
THB 37.979343
TJS 10.762507
TMT 4.080661
TND 3.374168
TOP 2.807215
TRY 53.459583
TTD 7.920707
TWD 36.640613
TZS 3065.839407
UAH 51.641442
UGX 4395.364568
USD 1.165903
UYU 46.767721
UZS 14017.076029
VES 639.713683
VND 30677.82924
VUV 137.641842
WST 3.165657
XAF 656.927964
XAG 0.015488
XAU 0.000257
XCD 3.150912
XCG 2.101443
XDR 0.815557
XOF 655.824767
XPF 119.331742
YER 278.188699
ZAR 19.000364
ZMK 10494.532504
ZMW 21.432678
ZWL 375.42037
  • CMSC

    -0.1000

    22.74

    -0.44%

  • BP

    0.2800

    41.87

    +0.67%

  • BTI

    -1.1300

    61.79

    -1.83%

  • BCE

    0.2000

    25.11

    +0.8%

  • RIO

    -0.0800

    106.39

    -0.08%

  • CMSD

    0.0400

    22.93

    +0.17%

  • BCC

    -0.6300

    69.72

    -0.9%

  • AZN

    0.3400

    185.67

    +0.18%

  • NGG

    -1.1562

    81.53

    -1.42%

  • GSK

    -0.7000

    50.54

    -1.39%

  • RBGPF

    -0.0100

    63.54

    -0.02%

  • RELX

    -0.3100

    32.79

    -0.95%

  • VOD

    0.0300

    14.96

    +0.2%

  • JRI

    0.0600

    12.92

    +0.46%

  • RYCEF

    0.7000

    18

    +3.89%

Hosting Britain's migrants: The view from Rwanda
Hosting Britain's migrants: The view from Rwanda / Photo: Ben Stansall - AFP/File

Hosting Britain's migrants: The view from Rwanda

Britain's controversial deal to send migrants and asylum-seekers to Rwanda has attracted a flood of criticism in the UK, with opposition politicians, campaigners and the UN refugee agency calling for the multi-million-dollar agreement to be scrapped.

Text size:

But little has been said about the view from Rwanda -- a tiny nation of 13 million people in Africa's Great Lakes region that has drawn praise for its modern infrastructure but sparked unease over its record on human rights.

Here is a look at Kigali's reasons for signing the deal and the challenges ahead:

- Why is Rwanda doing this? -

The deal will be funded by the UK to the tune of up to £120 million ($157 million, 144 million euros), but observers say cash may not be Kigali's main motivation.

President Paul Kagame has sought to position Rwanda as a Western ally and firefighter for conflicts across Africa, sending thousands of troops to battle Islamic State-linked jihadists in Mozambique last year.

The deal is aimed at bolstering Rwanda's international prestige and deflect concern over its handling of human rights, Kigali-based lawyer and analyst Louis Gitinywa told AFP.

"President Kagame is eyeing to leverage this agreement as a vote of confidence (in) his human rights record," Gitinywa said.

It will burnish the profile of Kagame, who has kept tight control over Rwanda since the 1994 genocide, "as a key African leader -- a kind of Mister-Fix-it" for the continent, Gitinywa added.

"This also probably ensures that President Kagame (has) secured the diplomatic backing of the UK when resolutions against Rwanda are submitted and discussed at the UN Security Council."

- How will this affect Rwanda's human rights record? -

In January last year, the British government took Kigali to task over "continued restrictions to civil and political rights and media freedom".

But last week, Prime Minister Boris Johnson appeared to have reversed course, hailing Rwanda as "one of the safest countries in the world, globally recognised for its record of welcoming and integrating migrants".

The contradictory comments offered a glimpse of how the deal might help Kigali rewrite the public narrative around its treatment of dissidents, including those who have fled abroad.

"Rwanda has routinely demonstrated how it holds protections afforded refugees under international law in low regard," said Lewis Mudge, Central Africa director at Human Rights Watch.

"There are credible allegations that Rwandan agents carried out assassinations of Rwandan refugees abroad and many refugees fear the Rwandan government's long arm as far afield as Europe, Canada or Australia," he told AFP.

Last September, "Hotel Rwanda" hero and Kagame critic Paul Rusesabagina was sentenced to 25 years in jail on terrorism charges, following his arrest in August 2020 when a plane he believed was bound for Burundi landed instead in Kigali in what his family called a kidnapping.

The country was ranked 156th out of 180 countries in the 2021 World Press Freedom Index compiled by Reporters Without Borders (RSF), a fall of one place over with 2020.

- How do Rwandans feel about the deal? -

Rwandans have largely stayed tight-lipped about the agreement, although some have praised it.

One positive voice is that of Tom Mulisa, lecturer of constitutional law at the University of Rwanda.

"It is a good thing that Rwanda has positioned itself in this way, as a way of contributing to solve the immigration crisis that is affecting the whole world," he told AFP.

Local journalist John Williams Ntwali is among the few willing to make his unease public, saying the agreement "violates the rights of refugees and asylum seekers."

"It is an immoral deal that forces people to go to a country that they did not choose," he added.

- What challenges will Rwanda face? -

Frank Habineza, president of the opposition Democratic Green Party of Rwanda, said the deal was not sustainable, pointing to already fierce competition for land and other resources.

"Taking on migrants from the UK will increase the land burden and survival challenges for the limited natural resources available," he said in a statement last week.

Opposition leader Victoire Ingabire, a fierce critic of Kagame, also highlighted the economic pressures facing the country following the Covid-19 pandemic.

"It is uncertain how Rwanda would support relocated migrants with their personal development and employment," she said.

"The Rwandan government (should) focus on solving its political and social internal issues that make its citizens... refugees in other countries before it offers to host refugees/migrants."

Rwanda has previously taken in African refugees stranded in Libya under an agreement with the African Union and the UN refugee agency. Last year it offered temporary asylum to Afghans fleeing a Taliban takeover.

Few details have been released about how the UK deal would be implemented. The accord is also widely expected to face a legal challenge that may force its architects to abandon it.

(T.Renner--BBZ)