Berliner Boersenzeitung - AI doomsayers blamed in OpenAI's undoing

EUR -
AED 4.324438
AFN 82.328185
ALL 97.949419
AMD 453.271707
ANG 2.107025
AOA 1079.636914
ARS 1449.927532
AUD 1.795358
AWG 2.122186
AZN 1.990127
BAM 1.954815
BBD 2.380071
BDT 144.607168
BGN 1.955302
BHD 0.443822
BIF 3511.586629
BMD 1.177357
BND 1.500925
BOB 8.145897
BRL 6.365024
BSD 1.178791
BTN 100.508378
BWP 15.572091
BYN 3.857757
BYR 23076.197533
BZD 2.367907
CAD 1.60034
CDF 3396.675125
CHF 0.934236
CLF 0.02847
CLP 1093.644109
CNY 8.436237
CNH 8.434891
COP 4697.183555
CRC 595.092696
CUC 1.177357
CUP 31.199961
CVE 110.209492
CZK 24.624403
DJF 209.911602
DKK 7.461312
DOP 70.463613
DZD 152.811006
EGP 58.09939
ERN 17.660355
ETB 162.604613
FJD 2.634572
FKP 0.862382
GBP 0.862196
GEL 3.202678
GGP 0.862382
GHS 12.200855
GIP 0.862382
GMD 84.181539
GNF 10220.808822
GTQ 9.063435
GYD 246.625785
HKD 9.242194
HNL 30.798357
HRK 7.534265
HTG 154.780072
HUF 398.487987
IDR 19055.287849
ILS 3.930624
IMP 0.862382
INR 100.608101
IQD 1544.202579
IRR 49596.16423
ISK 142.389078
JEP 0.862382
JMD 188.32435
JOD 0.834746
JPY 169.961488
KES 152.345617
KGS 102.959991
KHR 4731.556641
KMF 492.135408
KPW 1059.578096
KRW 1605.597618
KWD 0.359353
KYD 0.982393
KZT 612.503705
LAK 25399.88359
LBP 105621.403141
LKR 353.647378
LRD 236.35096
LSL 20.645002
LTL 3.476429
LVL 0.712172
LYD 6.347722
MAD 10.576473
MDL 19.851002
MGA 5177.370399
MKD 61.514133
MMK 2472.040219
MNT 4224.807876
MOP 9.5308
MRU 46.751453
MUR 52.922057
MVR 18.128529
MWK 2044.161764
MXN 21.964892
MYR 4.973745
MZN 75.303303
NAD 20.644739
NGN 1800.6381
NIO 43.377968
NOK 11.869454
NPR 160.810958
NZD 1.941497
OMR 0.452699
PAB 1.178806
PEN 4.198286
PGK 4.866528
PHP 66.42671
PKR 334.519655
PLN 4.249107
PYG 9398.14683
QAR 4.295936
RON 5.059923
RSD 117.183551
RUB 92.839359
RWF 1693.339948
SAR 4.415489
SBD 9.815536
SCR 17.271949
SDG 706.982177
SEK 11.24715
SGD 1.499715
SHP 0.925218
SLE 26.431679
SLL 24688.592283
SOS 673.657847
SRD 43.779986
STD 24368.913178
SVC 10.314674
SYP 15308.030561
SZL 20.654334
THB 38.075993
TJS 11.428398
TMT 4.132523
TND 3.429373
TOP 2.757486
TRY 46.920697
TTD 7.986876
TWD 34.069761
TZS 3114.646199
UAH 49.220701
UGX 4228.870104
USD 1.177357
UYU 47.226214
UZS 14843.523969
VES 128.889394
VND 30817.908599
VUV 140.260432
WST 3.06316
XAF 655.624007
XAG 0.031985
XAU 0.000352
XCD 3.181866
XDR 0.815386
XOF 655.618441
XPF 119.331742
YER 285.096832
ZAR 20.707824
ZMK 10597.623008
ZMW 28.438677
ZWL 379.108479
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

AI doomsayers blamed in OpenAI's undoing
AI doomsayers blamed in OpenAI's undoing / Photo: OLIVIER DOULIERY - AFP

AI doomsayers blamed in OpenAI's undoing

OpenAI has gone from ruling the world of artificial intelligence with ChatGPT to chaos, its chief executive ousted seemingly for advancing too fast and too far with the risky technology.

Text size:

The exit of Sam Altman set in motion a series of events that saw the upstart company's biggest investor, Microsoft, swoop in to hire the toppled CEO and begin a process of building an OpenAI clone in the Redmond, Washington-based tech giant.

In some ways the looming result to the weekend saga is hardly a surprise, with many wondering how the board members could be naive enough to think they could win the duel with the Microsoft-backed Altman.

Microsoft pumped over $10 billion into OpenAI earlier this year to the point that critics, including ultra-wealthy entrepreneur Elon Musk, said the hot startup was owned by the Windows software maker in all but name.

"Microsoft is providing vast amounts of money and computational power and some of that of course ends up having some influence," said Brendan Dolan-Gavitt, an associate professor at New York University.

Silicon Valley was left aghast by the Friday firing of tech celebrity Altman, with the investor community, and entirety of OpenAI's own staff, furious that the four-person board got in the way of building the AI age.

"We are not happy about it. We want stability here," said Ryan Steelberg, CEO of Veritone, a company that helps firms develop artificial intelligence.

Instead of OpenAI becoming the new Apple or Google, the harsh critics see a deeply troubled startup that fell victim to the pearl-clutching of an incompetent board that was divorced from reality.

"We reached this point because minuscule risks have been hysterically amplified by the exotic thinking of sci-fi mindsets, and clickbait journalism from the press," said veteran venture capitalist Vinod Khosla, an early investor in OpenAI.

- 'Fallible people' -

But other observers less concerned with turning AI into big bucks warned that the drama in San Francisco meant that something so vital shouldn't be left in the hands of the inexperienced or the profit driven.

"This is an important reminder that as brilliant as the designers of tech like AI -- scientists or engineers -- are, they are still just fallible people," said Paul Barrett, deputy director of the NYU Stern Center for Business and Human Rights.

"That is why it is important not to just defer to them on a technology that everyone agrees has significant risks even as it promises tremendous benefits," he added.

Gary Marcus, a respected AI expert, said OpenAI's civil war "highlights the fact that we can't really trust the companies to self-regulate AI where even their own internal governance can be deeply conflicted."

Government regulation, notably by the tougher-minded European Union, was needed more than ever, he added.

OpenAI was actually created in 2015 with the goal of being a counterweight to Google, which was by far the leader in developing AI technologies that mimic the operations of the human brain.

Though nothing is known for sure, assumptions are rife that Altman's increased efforts to monetize the company's leading GPT-4 model, all while keeping its inner functioning a secret, was becoming problematic for the company's board.

Already, several senior staff at OpenAI deserted the enterprise to build Anthropic.AI over concerns that Altman was moving ahead too recklessly.

- 'OpenAI is done' -

Many are shocked that the board had the power it did, or were naive enough to think they could actually use it.

Three of those board members are thought to have connections to the effective altruism movement, which frets over the risks of AI, but that critics say is cut from reality.

Whatever their beliefs, by Monday the board were overseeing a company in name only, with virtually the whole staff committed to a pledge of seeing them go or quitting the firm for Altman's project at Microsoft.

"Unless OpenAI can block those departures, OpenAI is pretty much done at this point," analyst Rob Enderle told AFP.

This could mean a history-making victory for Microsoft, which has already seen its share price reach record levels over its ties to OpenAI.

"This is like the best possible scenario for them, and the OpenAI board I am sure is kicking itself. They were clearly detached from reality," said Carolina Milanesi, analyst at Creative Strategies.

(L.Kaufmann--BBZ)