Berliner Boersenzeitung - The centuries-old mines stirring Japan-South Korea tensions

EUR -
AED 4.272706
AFN 80.277121
ALL 97.263968
AMD 445.385554
ANG 2.082293
AOA 1066.868798
ARS 1581.221574
AUD 1.792628
AWG 2.09418
AZN 1.974867
BAM 1.945654
BBD 2.342436
BDT 141.561828
BGN 1.955962
BHD 0.438635
BIF 3433.291644
BMD 1.163433
BND 1.49296
BOB 8.052185
BRL 6.295574
BSD 1.162762
BTN 101.76802
BWP 15.560196
BYN 3.930653
BYR 22803.292516
BZD 2.332607
CAD 1.611675
CDF 3336.72608
CHF 0.936756
CLF 0.028549
CLP 1119.956271
CNY 8.320297
CNH 8.322922
COP 4683.691574
CRC 585.459708
CUC 1.163433
CUP 30.830982
CVE 110.701007
CZK 24.555132
DJF 206.765441
DKK 7.46364
DOP 73.005295
DZD 150.867546
EGP 56.41244
ERN 17.451499
ETB 164.624
FJD 2.636458
FKP 0.864164
GBP 0.863849
GEL 3.135462
GGP 0.864164
GHS 12.797526
GIP 0.864164
GMD 83.185593
GNF 10098.600703
GTQ 8.915777
GYD 243.268796
HKD 9.087589
HNL 30.708857
HRK 7.54743
HTG 152.141238
HUF 397.271166
IDR 18934.004247
ILS 3.913382
IMP 0.864164
INR 101.927053
IQD 1524.097612
IRR 48936.917674
ISK 143.416617
JEP 0.864164
JMD 186.218964
JOD 0.824894
JPY 171.440619
KES 150.662086
KGS 101.649865
KHR 4660.714119
KMF 485.151864
KPW 1047.074341
KRW 1615.217622
KWD 0.355569
KYD 0.968968
KZT 622.515873
LAK 25153.427969
LBP 104191.268606
LKR 351.176341
LRD 235.013864
LSL 20.510786
LTL 3.435316
LVL 0.703749
LYD 6.293688
MAD 10.520925
MDL 19.441043
MGA 5188.912275
MKD 61.611962
MMK 2442.610375
MNT 4181.786015
MOP 9.355696
MRU 46.479006
MUR 53.110968
MVR 17.914432
MWK 2020.883783
MXN 21.726035
MYR 4.898181
MZN 74.401577
NAD 20.511527
NGN 1788.317619
NIO 42.825284
NOK 11.767866
NPR 162.828832
NZD 1.985841
OMR 0.447306
PAB 1.162777
PEN 4.095432
PGK 4.823304
PHP 66.053979
PKR 327.942723
PLN 4.259916
PYG 8427.057215
QAR 4.23577
RON 5.052094
RSD 117.121734
RUB 93.892714
RWF 1682.32454
SAR 4.365094
SBD 9.560008
SCR 16.440063
SDG 698.642243
SEK 11.141856
SGD 1.494506
SHP 0.914276
SLE 27.108909
SLL 24396.612048
SOS 664.900741
SRD 44.477482
STD 24080.720175
STN 24.897472
SVC 10.173948
SYP 15126.861809
SZL 20.511569
THB 37.776351
TJS 11.115871
TMT 4.083651
TND 3.356526
TOP 2.724874
TRY 47.710655
TTD 7.9007
TWD 35.436548
TZS 2914.401023
UAH 48.23314
UGX 4142.488062
USD 1.163433
UYU 46.59702
UZS 14368.400658
VES 162.009994
VND 30604.112737
VUV 140.096052
WST 3.154668
XAF 652.576584
XAG 0.030213
XAU 0.000346
XCD 3.144236
XCG 2.095446
XDR 0.811336
XOF 652.686367
XPF 119.331742
YER 279.427601
ZAR 20.48254
ZMK 10472.280474
ZMW 27.085346
ZWL 374.625045
  • RBGPF

    2.0800

    76

    +2.74%

  • CMSD

    0.0700

    24.02

    +0.29%

  • NGG

    -0.9200

    70.49

    -1.31%

  • SCS

    -0.1100

    16.39

    -0.67%

  • RYCEF

    0.1400

    14.2

    +0.99%

  • CMSC

    0.0500

    23.8

    +0.21%

  • AZN

    -1.3100

    79.66

    -1.64%

  • RIO

    -0.3600

    62.33

    -0.58%

  • BTI

    -0.7100

    57.8

    -1.23%

  • GSK

    -0.5500

    39.64

    -1.39%

  • RELX

    -0.6500

    47.79

    -1.36%

  • VOD

    -0.0500

    11.87

    -0.42%

  • JRI

    -0.0200

    13.43

    -0.15%

  • BCE

    -0.2700

    25.22

    -1.07%

  • BCC

    -1.2400

    89.98

    -1.38%

  • BP

    0.2300

    34.97

    +0.66%

The centuries-old mines stirring Japan-South Korea tensions
The centuries-old mines stirring Japan-South Korea tensions / Photo: Charly TRIBALLEAU - AFP

The centuries-old mines stirring Japan-South Korea tensions

Under a split-top mountain on the Japanese island of Sado lies a network of centuries-old mines that have sparked a new diplomatic row with South Korea.

Text size:

Some of the gold and silver mines of Sado, off Japan's west coast, are believed to have started operating as early as the 12th century and produced until after World War II.

Japan believes that lengthy history and the artisanal mining techniques used there at a time when European mines had turned to mechanisation merit recognition on UNESCO's World Heritage List.

But in Seoul, the focus is on what isn't mentioned in the bid: the use of conscripted Korean labour during the Second World War, when Japan occupied the Korean peninsula.

Japan is seeking recognition of three sites -- the Nishimikawa gold mine, the Tsurushi silver mine, and the Aikawa gold and silver mines -- for the period between 1603 and 1867.

Officials and supporters of the bid say that era was when the mines were the world's most productive and mining was done by hand.

But it also stops short of the period when conscripted Koreans toiled in conditions that even some backers of the UNESCO bid call "extremely harsh".

The World Heritage effort has been years in the making, inspired in part by the successful recognition of a silver mine in western Japan's Shimane region.

Ryo Usami, from Sado city's World Heritage Promotion section, said locals hoped the recognition would highlight the mine's contributions to the unique culture and history of the island.

"Many people migrated to Sado to mine gold and silver... They came from all over Japan and brought their local cultures," Usami told AFP.

"Sado's history is basically the history of these gold mines, and its culture formed in part thanks to the mining operations. That's what Sado city wants to preserve."

- 'Discrimination did exist' -

Production at the sites petered out by the 1960s, when mine operator Mitsubishi Materials began accepting tourists.

In the 1970s, animatronic robots were installed in some mining tunnels to give a sense of what life there was like.

The eerie, rundown figures remain, their heads swivelling side-to-side and arms mechanically swinging pickaxes up and down in a forlorn fashion.

Groups of domestic tourists file through the frigid tunnels and read panels that explain the history of Sado's mining industry.

The panels note that Edo-era miners were often homeless or unregistered people who were captured and forced to work, and that child labour was used at times.

But there is little to testify that an estimated 1,500 Koreans worked at the sites during World War II.

Their status is disputed, with some arguing around two-thirds signed contracts voluntarily, while the remainder were conscripted during war-time mobilisation.

"The working conditions were extremely harsh, nevertheless the pay was very high, that's why lots of people, including many Japanese, applied," said Koichiro Matsuura, a former UNESCO director-general who is backing Sado's bid.

Others argue the recruitment conditions effectively amounted to forced labour, and that Korean workers faced significantly harsher conditions than their Japanese counterparts.

"Discrimination did exist," said Toyomi Asano, a professor of history of Japanese politics at Tokyo's Waseda University.

"Their working conditions were very bad and dangerous. The most dangerous jobs were allocated to them."

- 'A part of our history' -

Wartime issues like forced labour have soured ties between Japan and South Korea, and Seoul has formed a task force to push back against the UNESCO bid.

After the bid was announced, the government summoned Tokyo's ambassador and issued a statement saying it "strongly regrets" the nomination and "sternly urges Japan to stop its attempt".

The issue of forced labour affects other Japanese heritage sites, including the "Sites of the Meiji Industrial Revolution" inscribed in 2015.

UNESCO last year demanded an information centre for the sites properly explain that a "large number of Koreans and others (were) brought against their will and forced to work under harsh conditions".

Matsuura believes Japan must "avoid making the same mistake" at Sado.

"We must say in a more concrete and more honest manner how the Korean workers lived and worked at the Sado gold mines."

It's a view shared by some visitors, including 79-year-old Hideji Yamagami.

"Of course they should (explain), I didn't know about it at all," he told AFP after a trip through the Aikawa site.

"I thought it was Japanese who had done all the hard work."

Asano hopes UNESCO will insist the full history of Sado's mines is on display if the site gets World Heritage status, and believes Japan "should not fear" recognising a part of its history.

"Every nation has its dark history, those nations who are completely exempt do not exist."

(Y.Berger--BBZ)