Berliner Boersenzeitung - Russian captain found guilty in fatal North Sea crash

EUR -
AED 4.331023
AFN 77.824044
ALL 96.204991
AMD 446.932449
ANG 2.110769
AOA 1081.2786
ARS 1712.071881
AUD 1.697104
AWG 2.122466
AZN 2.007924
BAM 1.945772
BBD 2.377447
BDT 144.365962
BGN 1.980226
BHD 0.444554
BIF 3495.583857
BMD 1.179148
BND 1.499385
BOB 8.186157
BRL 6.208092
BSD 1.180416
BTN 107.944132
BWP 15.536586
BYN 3.37998
BYR 23111.298228
BZD 2.373975
CAD 1.614548
CDF 2541.063785
CHF 0.92033
CLF 0.025849
CLP 1020.682673
CNY 8.190951
CNH 8.184436
COP 4260.603203
CRC 585.686437
CUC 1.179148
CUP 31.247419
CVE 109.699626
CZK 24.301878
DJF 209.557895
DKK 7.468724
DOP 74.227828
DZD 153.236192
EGP 55.532091
ERN 17.687218
ETB 184.008454
FJD 2.627969
FKP 0.860488
GBP 0.863461
GEL 3.177812
GGP 0.860488
GHS 12.943292
GIP 0.860488
GMD 86.077934
GNF 10357.749649
GTQ 9.05732
GYD 246.967642
HKD 9.209086
HNL 31.15941
HRK 7.528271
HTG 154.704646
HUF 380.935486
IDR 19781.384647
ILS 3.656349
IMP 0.860488
INR 107.264075
IQD 1546.330471
IRR 49671.604158
ISK 145.212068
JEP 0.860488
JMD 185.337161
JOD 0.835984
JPY 183.495423
KES 152.263492
KGS 103.115876
KHR 4752.706874
KMF 489.346754
KPW 1061.233082
KRW 1712.346624
KWD 0.362222
KYD 0.983672
KZT 596.092892
LAK 25385.276168
LBP 105707.384156
LKR 365.540714
LRD 218.970746
LSL 18.8985
LTL 3.481717
LVL 0.713255
LYD 7.457659
MAD 10.764223
MDL 19.984849
MGA 5263.893095
MKD 61.629401
MMK 2476.194563
MNT 4203.220257
MOP 9.495959
MRU 46.872427
MUR 53.827748
MVR 18.229311
MWK 2046.76002
MXN 20.530367
MYR 4.648174
MZN 75.182584
NAD 18.8985
NGN 1644.156287
NIO 43.436137
NOK 11.451318
NPR 172.711339
NZD 1.965421
OMR 0.453398
PAB 1.180421
PEN 3.97571
PGK 5.057932
PHP 69.416105
PKR 330.421765
PLN 4.221797
PYG 7848.549884
QAR 4.315061
RON 5.095451
RSD 117.405364
RUB 90.14055
RWF 1725.705999
SAR 4.422011
SBD 9.494043
SCR 17.685253
SDG 709.260254
SEK 10.58085
SGD 1.500743
SHP 0.884666
SLE 28.682728
SLL 24726.14037
SOS 674.628797
SRD 44.837082
STD 24405.980193
STN 24.374379
SVC 10.328898
SYP 13040.874167
SZL 18.889646
THB 37.237836
TJS 11.024827
TMT 4.127018
TND 3.405548
TOP 2.839105
TRY 51.257794
TTD 7.991879
TWD 37.251051
TZS 3052.21225
UAH 50.836046
UGX 4216.270048
USD 1.179148
UYU 45.793985
UZS 14430.626958
VES 436.038953
VND 30681.427545
VUV 140.503382
WST 3.196411
XAF 652.621173
XAG 0.014976
XAU 0.000253
XCD 3.186706
XCG 2.127336
XDR 0.810328
XOF 652.593641
XPF 119.331742
YER 281.020373
ZAR 19.00208
ZMK 10613.749147
ZMW 23.165591
ZWL 379.685133
  • RBGPF

    0.1000

    82.5

    +0.12%

  • SCS

    0.0200

    16.14

    +0.12%

  • RYCEF

    0.7000

    16.7

    +4.19%

  • CMSC

    -0.0480

    23.712

    -0.2%

  • BCC

    1.3400

    82.15

    +1.63%

  • JRI

    0.0750

    13.155

    +0.57%

  • VOD

    0.2500

    14.9

    +1.68%

  • NGG

    -0.4300

    84.84

    -0.51%

  • RIO

    1.1100

    92.14

    +1.2%

  • CMSD

    0.0480

    24.098

    +0.2%

  • GSK

    0.8600

    52.46

    +1.64%

  • RELX

    -0.3250

    35.475

    -0.92%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    25.8

    -0.23%

  • BTI

    0.0850

    60.765

    +0.14%

  • BP

    -0.1750

    37.705

    -0.46%

  • AZN

    1.9500

    192.39

    +1.01%

Russian captain found guilty in fatal North Sea crash
Russian captain found guilty in fatal North Sea crash / Photo: Paul ELLIS - AFP

Russian captain found guilty in fatal North Sea crash

The Russian captain of a cargo ship that hit an anchored oil tanker in the North Sea last year was on Monday found guilty by a UK court of killing a crew member.

Text size:

After eight hours of deliberation, the jury convicted Vladimir Motin of the manslaughter by gross negligence of Filipino sailor Mark Angelo Pernia.

The seaman, 38, who was married with a young child, was lost at sea following the crash in which Motin's cargo ship, the Solong, collided with the oil-laden Stena Immaculate, triggering a fiery blaze off the eastern UK coast.

Pernia's body has never been recovered.

Motin, from Saint Petersburg, showed no emotion as he was convicted by a jury at London's Old Bailey court.

He was remanded in custody and will be sentenced on Thursday.

Speaking after the verdict, investigating officer Craig Nicholson described the crash as a "senseless tragedy".

"It's a miracle that there weren't more fatalities or serious injuries," he said.

Prosecutor Tom Little told the court Pernia's wife -- who was seven months pregnant with their second child at the time of his death -- lived in a remote area of the Philippines.

She would need to make arrangements to travel somewhere with good internet access to watch the sentencing remotely.

"This was a tragic, and entirely avoidable death of a member of crew caused by truly, exceptionally bad negligence," said prosecutor Michael Gregory.

"It is with great sadness for his family that his body has never been found," he added.

- 'Collision course' -

The collision at speed in March set both vessels ablaze and triggered a massive offshore rescue operation.

Motin's defence lawyer, James Leonard, had previously told the trial that the captain had attempted to take the Portuguese-flagged Solong out of autopilot and change course manually to avoid crashing into the Stena Immaculate, which had been chartered by the US military.

"That attempt, however, was not successful and the Solong did not change course at all," he said.

Motin told the court he had made a "mistake" and pressed the wrong button.

The jury was told Motin was a "highly trained" sailor who had captained the Solong for 15 years.

But the prosecution insisted that he "did nothing to avoid the collision".

"He could, and should, have acted differently" when his ship was on "an obvious collision course" with the tanker, Little told the trial.

The CPS said the Solong's black box showed no course or speed adjustments before the collision.

It added that Motin had disabled the alarm system, "leaving him alone to be on watch as the eyes and ears of the ship".

WhatsApp messages sent to Motin by his wife had "undermined his credibility", the CPS noted.

She had told him to "think of an alibi and advised him to say he had not seen the other vessel on the control devices".

- 'Catastrophic' -

Audio recordings from the Solong's bridge control room were played to jurors, accompanied by a visual reconstruction of the ship's trajectory towards the Stena Immaculate.

An hour before the collision, men could be heard speaking calmly in Russian about the price of cigarettes. Then a Russian folksong is heard, an apparent phone ringtone which went unanswered.

As the Solong approached the anchored oil tanker, no conversation could be heard in the control room at all. The ensuing sound of the collision's initial impact was so loud that jurors winced after being warned to decrease the volume on their listening devices.

The jury saw phone footage recorded by Joesen Mariposila, the Solong's third-in-command, showing fire at the ship's other end.

He was heard saying "Lord help us" five times as dark smoke began to fill the air.

Malcolm McHaffie, head of the Crown Prosecution Service's special crime division, said the case underlined "the gravity of a captain's duty of care while out at sea".

"If that duty of care is breached, the consequences can be catastrophic."

(A.Berg--BBZ)