Berliner Boersenzeitung - 'Work without limits': Japan's teachers battle for change

EUR -
AED 4.343054
AFN 77.464136
ALL 96.578481
AMD 443.001294
ANG 2.116924
AOA 1084.432259
ARS 1696.425045
AUD 1.722632
AWG 2.13043
AZN 2.015092
BAM 1.955364
BBD 2.363473
BDT 143.548016
BGN 1.986001
BHD 0.442401
BIF 3475.425631
BMD 1.182587
BND 1.500966
BOB 8.109193
BRL 6.256361
BSD 1.173439
BTN 107.717999
BWP 16.277373
BYN 3.32206
BYR 23178.695489
BZD 2.360074
CAD 1.622687
CDF 2578.039008
CHF 0.922409
CLF 0.026073
CLP 1029.489324
CNY 8.24689
CNH 8.21806
COP 4228.657801
CRC 580.770597
CUC 1.182587
CUP 31.338542
CVE 110.240437
CZK 24.267271
DJF 208.973438
DKK 7.466899
DOP 73.933527
DZD 153.154875
EGP 55.703589
ERN 17.738798
ETB 182.791072
FJD 2.661179
FKP 0.870315
GBP 0.866681
GEL 3.18162
GGP 0.870315
GHS 12.79115
GIP 0.870315
GMD 86.329235
GNF 10278.709772
GTQ 9.006993
GYD 245.515296
HKD 9.221278
HNL 30.954103
HRK 7.533317
HTG 153.905708
HUF 382.153287
IDR 19840.785951
ILS 3.707232
IMP 0.870315
INR 108.316693
IQD 1537.357457
IRR 49816.456691
ISK 145.777895
JEP 0.870315
JMD 184.718842
JOD 0.838501
JPY 184.146504
KES 151.256298
KGS 103.416722
KHR 4722.947667
KMF 496.686746
KPW 1064.353704
KRW 1710.387141
KWD 0.362349
KYD 0.977982
KZT 590.738376
LAK 25359.349612
LBP 105085.885516
LKR 363.548997
LRD 217.091629
LSL 18.94048
LTL 3.491871
LVL 0.715335
LYD 7.466336
MAD 10.748905
MDL 19.97255
MGA 5308.817127
MKD 61.616271
MMK 2483.187819
MNT 4218.830116
MOP 9.4253
MRU 46.916546
MUR 54.292994
MVR 18.271409
MWK 2034.84661
MXN 20.533372
MYR 4.736855
MZN 75.57955
NAD 18.94048
NGN 1680.526824
NIO 43.180379
NOK 11.555294
NPR 172.348599
NZD 1.987207
OMR 0.454249
PAB 1.173539
PEN 3.936823
PGK 5.018882
PHP 69.733624
PKR 328.342141
PLN 4.208885
PYG 7847.251532
QAR 4.278347
RON 5.101724
RSD 117.373848
RUB 89.207823
RWF 1711.518652
SAR 4.433442
SBD 9.606873
SCR 16.856244
SDG 711.330129
SEK 10.584272
SGD 1.505082
SHP 0.887246
SLE 28.859447
SLL 24798.24684
SOS 669.450838
SRD 45.081425
STD 24477.153012
STN 24.494542
SVC 10.267712
SYP 13078.904017
SZL 18.935781
THB 36.920787
TJS 10.972155
TMT 4.139053
TND 3.416239
TOP 2.847384
TRY 51.246799
TTD 7.971224
TWD 37.116428
TZS 3004.130641
UAH 50.599026
UGX 4148.075755
USD 1.182587
UYU 44.440098
UZS 14242.826515
VES 416.584326
VND 31036.982812
VUV 141.661813
WST 3.258757
XAF 655.810877
XAG 0.011483
XAU 0.000237
XCD 3.196
XCG 2.114929
XDR 0.815618
XOF 655.810877
XPF 119.331742
YER 281.814608
ZAR 19.0597
ZMK 10644.701884
ZMW 23.02187
ZWL 380.792372
  • SCS

    0.0200

    16.14

    +0.12%

  • RBGPF

    -0.8100

    83.23

    -0.97%

  • NGG

    1.3200

    81.5

    +1.62%

  • BCC

    -1.1800

    84.33

    -1.4%

  • GSK

    0.5000

    49.15

    +1.02%

  • CMSC

    0.1000

    23.75

    +0.42%

  • RELX

    0.0600

    39.9

    +0.15%

  • BCE

    0.4900

    25.2

    +1.94%

  • RYCEF

    0.3000

    17.12

    +1.75%

  • BTI

    0.9400

    59.16

    +1.59%

  • RIO

    3.1300

    90.43

    +3.46%

  • CMSD

    0.0900

    24.13

    +0.37%

  • AZN

    1.2600

    92.95

    +1.36%

  • JRI

    0.0100

    13.68

    +0.07%

  • VOD

    0.2300

    14.17

    +1.62%

  • BP

    1.1000

    36.53

    +3.01%

'Work without limits': Japan's teachers battle for change
'Work without limits': Japan's teachers battle for change / Photo: Kazuhiro NOGI - AFP

'Work without limits': Japan's teachers battle for change

In one of his last diary entries, Japanese teacher Yoshio Kudo lamented workdays that started early and could last until nearly midnight. Two months later, he suffered "karoshi" -- death from overwork.

Text size:

Kudo's taxing schedule was far from an exception in Japan, where teachers work some of the longest hours in the world, saddled with tasks from cleaning and supervising school commutes to after-school clubs.

A 2018 OECD survey found Japanese middle school teachers work 56 hours a week, versus an average 38 hours in most developed countries.

But that still fails to account for astonishing amounts of overtime.

One probe by a union-affiliated think tank showed school teachers work an average 123 hours of overtime each month, pushing their weekly workload well beyond the so-called "karoshi line" of 80 hours.

Teachers say they are reaching the breaking point, and some have challenged the culture through lawsuits. This year, Japan's ruling party established a task force to study the issue.

That came too late for Kudo, a middle school teacher, who died of a brain haemorrhage aged 40 in 2007.

At his funeral, stunned students told his wife Sachiko that the lively physical education teacher was the "furthest imaginable person from death".

"He just loved working with kids," Sachiko, 55, told AFP.

But in his final weeks, he was struggling with his hours.

"Towards the end, he was telling me that teachers should stop working like this and that he wanted to lead that change in the future," his widow said.

- 'Kiss your weekends goodbye' -

Japanese authorities have ordered steps including outsourcing and digitalising some tasks.

"Our measures to reform work conditions for teachers are making steady progress," education minister Keiko Nagaoka told parliament in October.

But she acknowledged that many "continue to work long hours" and "efforts need to be accelerated".

Education ministry data shows a gradual decline in overtime, but experts see little fundamental change.

From reams of paperwork to tasks like lunch distribution, leading daily cleaning sessions with students and monitoring children on their way to and from school, teachers in Japan "have in a way become handymen", school management consultant Masatoshi Senoo said.

"What should really be the responsibility of parents sometimes spills over onto teachers, who can even be sent to apologise to local residents when students misbehave at parks or convenience stores," he said.

One of the most all-consuming tasks is the supervision of student sports and cultural "club" activities, typically conducted after school and on weekends.

"Being assigned as primary supervisor of one of these clubs usually means you have to kiss your weekends goodbye," said Takeshi Nishimoto, a high school history teacher in Osaka.

In June, Nishimoto, 34, won a rare lawsuit seeking compensation for stress from overwork.

He filed the suit after coming close to a nervous breakdown in 2017, when the then-rugby club supervisor worked 144 hours of overtime in a single month.

- 'Sacred job' -

Experts say teachers are particularly vulnerable to overwork because of a decades-old law that essentially prevents them from being paid for overtime.

Instead, the law adds eight hours' worth of extra pay to their monthly salaries, a framework that Nishimoto says results in "making teachers work without limits for fixed pay".

Masako Shimonomura, a middle school physical education teacher in Tokyo's Edogawa district, says it can feel hard to take a proper break in her day.

"Not everything about this job is 'black' though," she said, using a Japanese term for exploitative labour.

"There are some moments I live for, like watching students in my softball club shine and smile at tournaments," said the 56-year-old, whose desk is covered with stacks of files and documents.

But she fears that if conditions don't improve, "the image of our profession as 'black' will dominate for younger generations".

An investigation by the Mainichi newspaper revealed that in the decade to 2016, there were 63 public school teacher deaths classified as caused by overwork.

But it took Kudo's widow five years to get her husband's death recognised as karoshi, a task complicated by the lack of records for his work hours.

She says teaching is often seen as a "sacred job" devoted to children, so anything viewed as selfish -- including taking note of hours worked -- can be frowned upon.

"So many teachers regret that they lived their lives without stopping to enjoy the growth of their own children," she said.

A former schoolteacher herself, Sachiko now heads an anti-karoshi group in central Japan.

"I feel like my husband and I are working together to follow through on his last words -- that he wants to change the working practices of teachers".

(Y.Yildiz--BBZ)