Berliner Boersenzeitung - Hong Kong and Singapore virus response a tale of two very different cities

EUR -
AED 4.272332
AFN 80.42513
ALL 97.618365
AMD 447.08411
ANG 2.081722
AOA 1066.625747
ARS 1482.668999
AUD 1.786354
AWG 2.093704
AZN 1.978062
BAM 1.956168
BBD 2.350642
BDT 141.33659
BGN 1.957659
BHD 0.438683
BIF 3469.652746
BMD 1.163169
BND 1.494381
BOB 8.044513
BRL 6.49316
BSD 1.164219
BTN 100.225856
BWP 15.630941
BYN 3.810017
BYR 22798.109012
BZD 2.33854
CAD 1.596339
CDF 3356.905613
CHF 0.931855
CLF 0.029216
CLP 1121.166966
CNY 8.349168
CNH 8.350808
COP 4677.985862
CRC 587.510528
CUC 1.163169
CUP 30.823974
CVE 110.285748
CZK 24.639171
DJF 207.108963
DKK 7.464619
DOP 70.313228
DZD 151.632527
EGP 57.473915
ERN 17.447532
ETB 161.762232
FJD 2.62283
FKP 0.867122
GBP 0.86695
GEL 3.152504
GGP 0.867122
GHS 12.137283
GIP 0.867122
GMD 83.169137
GNF 10101.900472
GTQ 8.938682
GYD 243.575824
HKD 9.128374
HNL 30.469732
HRK 7.534655
HTG 152.858757
HUF 399.327066
IDR 18992.220609
ILS 3.905799
IMP 0.867122
INR 100.205657
IQD 1525.086915
IRR 48983.951758
ISK 142.394978
JEP 0.867122
JMD 186.175025
JOD 0.824691
JPY 172.533407
KES 150.420989
KGS 101.719181
KHR 4665.877792
KMF 492.368475
KPW 1046.851956
KRW 1617.560714
KWD 0.355511
KYD 0.970183
KZT 620.63676
LAK 25106.723332
LBP 104314.024614
LKR 351.24608
LRD 233.423914
LSL 20.612978
LTL 3.434535
LVL 0.703589
LYD 6.332191
MAD 10.527381
MDL 19.803726
MGA 5180.974698
MKD 61.571583
MMK 2442.318183
MNT 4170.955634
MOP 9.412171
MRU 46.311713
MUR 53.145273
MVR 17.947427
MWK 2018.779793
MXN 21.773532
MYR 4.934746
MZN 74.396717
NAD 20.612978
NGN 1779.101521
NIO 42.848061
NOK 11.836209
NPR 160.361169
NZD 1.954985
OMR 0.447344
PAB 1.164219
PEN 4.14408
PGK 4.820907
PHP 66.320372
PKR 331.569578
PLN 4.248337
PYG 9010.695183
QAR 4.232996
RON 5.070955
RSD 117.172044
RUB 91.430301
RWF 1682.316494
SAR 4.365055
SBD 9.65296
SCR 17.095616
SDG 698.482539
SEK 11.232448
SGD 1.494154
SHP 0.914068
SLE 26.639281
SLL 24391.073311
SOS 665.325168
SRD 43.279196
STD 24075.246293
STN 24.50461
SVC 10.186916
SYP 15123.352623
SZL 20.608877
THB 37.674798
TJS 11.205608
TMT 4.082723
TND 3.422544
TOP 2.724256
TRY 47.001673
TTD 7.903487
TWD 34.189007
TZS 3032.770825
UAH 48.620447
UGX 4171.784839
USD 1.163169
UYU 46.918827
UZS 14736.772431
VES 136.050029
VND 30428.496518
VUV 139.335512
WST 3.078793
XAF 656.080429
XAG 0.030437
XAU 0.000347
XCD 3.143522
XCG 2.098195
XDR 0.815954
XOF 656.080429
XPF 119.331742
YER 280.381842
ZAR 20.60507
ZMK 10469.912151
ZMW 26.806043
ZWL 374.539888
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

Hong Kong and Singapore virus response a tale of two very different cities
Hong Kong and Singapore virus response a tale of two very different cities

Hong Kong and Singapore virus response a tale of two very different cities

Rivals Singapore and Hong Kong have become pandemic polar opposites, the former opting to live with the coronavirus and reopen to the world while the latter doubles down on zero-Covid and its international isolation.

Text size:

For decades the two cities have jostled to be Asia's premier international business hub, offering low taxes, dependable legal systems and seamless global connections.

Both adopted strict suppression tactics when the pandemic emerged, closing borders to keep infections low within their densely populated territories.

Now they present competing visions as they manage the highly transmissible Omicron variant -- with Hong Kong floundering under soaring infections while Singapore offers a pandemic exit strategy.

In the heart of Singapore's financial district, analyst Camille Chautard sipped a coffee on a bench at Raffles Place during the busy lunchtime rush hour.

"Now that it seems the new variant is less deadly, or at least the infections are less severe, it's probably a good time for Singapore to lead the way in the region and open up," she told AFP.

Earlier this week, health minister Ong Ye Kung said Singapore was moving closer towards normalcy, noting that "Omicron poses less of a risk".

Hong Kong's leader Carrie Lam had a starkly different message.

Announcing compulsory testing for all 7.4 million residents, the tightest social distancing rules to date and plans to isolate all those infected, she said the city must "win the war".

"(Singapore) is miles ahead of Hong Kong in terms of dealing with these waves and especially mitigating the impact of the pandemic," Karen Grepin, a public health expert at the University of Hong Kong, told AFP.

- Openings vs closures -

The differences were clear on the streets this week.

In Singapore, children are back in class, residents are free to gather in hawker centres or enjoy post-work drinks, and people fly in and out for business or pleasure.

For Hong Kongers, in-person classes are suspended, businesses like bars and gyms remain closed, restaurants are only allowed to serve takeout in the evening, and international travel is increasingly impossible and involves lengthy quarantines.

"Zoom calls cannot replace the people-to-people connection...so (easing workplace restrictions) definitely helps," Singaporean businessman Vaibhav Dabhade told AFP.

"I believe that we still have an opportunity to open more, but so far the approach has been fantastic."

Such upbeat commentary is hard to come by in Hong Kong.

"The government's current zero-Covid policy seems to go against the trend," lamented a 39-year-old telecommunications worker surnamed Wong as he finished submitting to a Covid test outside a shopping mall in Sha Tin district.

"Every country around the world is living with the virus,” he added, describing the mass testing orders as a "waste".

- Politics vs health -

Hong Kong and Singapore are currently reporting thousands of infections per day and experts say the outbreak in both cities won't peak until sometime in March.

But as Hong Kong's healthcare and isolation system collapses, Singapore has so far avoided such a fate.

The city decided last fall to transition away from zero-Covid after realising it was not sustainable to isolate and hospitalise all the infected, Grepin said.

"We can't constantly live in that sphere, and I think Singapore is much better off because they recognised this early on," she said.

One key difference is the vaccination rate among the elderly.

Around 95 percent of Singaporeans aged 70 or above have received at least one dose of vaccine, while the figure in Hong Kong is 61 percent despite ample supplies.

That severely limits Hong Kong's ability to transition to living with the virus.

But there is another reason the city's hands are tied -- China.

Over the last six months Beijing has increasingly called the shots, ordering Hong Kong to stick to zero-Covid and decrying mitigation as a failed "Western" strategy.

Last week Chinese president Xi Jinping ordered Hong Kong to take "all necessary measures" to get the epidemic under control, reinforcing the reality that Hong Kong's post-pandemic future depends on Beijing.

"The decision to maintain a zero-Covid strategy after the advent of safe, effective vaccines is primarily a political decision as opposed to a public health decision," Grepin said.

- Travel vs isolation -

Singapore's approach has also come in for criticism, with some complaining about ever-changing, confusing restrictions.

And while the city's borders are slowly opening through quarantine-free travel with a number of countries, curbs are still tighter than in most Western countries, causing frustration for some foreign residents.

But compared to Hong Kong, which dubs itself "Asia's World City", travel ease is night and day.

Singapore's most recent data showed around 400,000 air passenger arrivals in December, while Hong Kong saw just 27,000 passengers in that same period.

"The longer (Hong Kong) endures the relatively restrictive mobility patterns compared to other hubs, the harder it will be to maintain its dominant position," Standard Chartered chief executive Bill Winters warned in a Financial Times report.

Even established mega-chains headquartered in Hong Kong are feeling the sting -- James Riley, chief executive of the Mandarin Oriental hotel giant, told the FT most of their executive team were now working outside the city.

"As a base from which to run a business, it's very, very poor today," Riley said.

In a January survey, the American Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong asked member companies which city represented the "greatest competitive threat".

Eighty percent answered Singapore.

(U.Gruber--BBZ)