Berliner Boersenzeitung - TotalEnergies in landmark greenwashing trial in France

EUR -
AED 4.317194
AFN 81.101956
ALL 97.499245
AMD 451.890977
ANG 2.103509
AOA 1077.834756
ARS 1447.508047
AUD 1.788866
AWG 2.118645
AZN 1.996417
BAM 1.949435
BBD 2.37355
BDT 144.20916
BGN 1.956188
BHD 0.443103
BIF 3455.653573
BMD 1.175392
BND 1.496813
BOB 8.123477
BRL 6.37369
BSD 1.175562
BTN 100.231746
BWP 15.529297
BYN 3.847139
BYR 23037.690484
BZD 2.36139
CAD 1.594414
CDF 3391.006847
CHF 0.935236
CLF 0.028409
CLP 1090.17705
CNY 8.42216
CNH 8.427851
COP 4689.815563
CRC 593.462359
CUC 1.175392
CUP 31.147898
CVE 110.339942
CZK 24.631111
DJF 208.890999
DKK 7.461115
DOP 70.347392
DZD 152.639957
EGP 58.001852
ERN 17.630886
ETB 159.207209
FJD 2.629586
FKP 0.86286
GBP 0.86131
GEL 3.197555
GGP 0.86286
GHS 12.165345
GIP 0.86286
GMD 84.043616
GNF 10174.196361
GTQ 9.03849
GYD 245.946989
HKD 9.226807
HNL 30.771549
HRK 7.535091
HTG 154.356031
HUF 398.769509
IDR 19078.028662
ILS 3.920662
IMP 0.86286
INR 100.396729
IQD 1539.764007
IRR 49513.403353
ISK 142.410553
JEP 0.86286
JMD 187.806815
JOD 0.833353
JPY 170.485955
KES 152.207613
KGS 102.787762
KHR 4726.252344
KMF 491.314092
KPW 1057.884384
KRW 1602.910014
KWD 0.358953
KYD 0.979701
KZT 610.825669
LAK 25335.5827
LBP 105315.156011
LKR 352.678513
LRD 235.665122
LSL 20.651303
LTL 3.470628
LVL 0.710983
LYD 6.323643
MAD 10.550615
MDL 19.796365
MGA 5212.864902
MKD 61.525386
MMK 2467.391102
MNT 4214.11342
MOP 9.504568
MRU 46.659729
MUR 52.704168
MVR 18.100048
MWK 2041.071836
MXN 21.952204
MYR 4.96309
MZN 75.178066
NAD 20.651589
NGN 1803.486634
NIO 43.19542
NOK 11.833304
NPR 160.370394
NZD 1.937753
OMR 0.451943
PAB 1.175562
PEN 4.179677
PGK 4.930788
PHP 66.285103
PKR 333.752413
PLN 4.241947
PYG 9372.399337
QAR 4.279136
RON 5.05901
RSD 117.194818
RUB 92.945398
RWF 1685.512661
SAR 4.408028
SBD 9.799157
SCR 16.554512
SDG 705.821976
SEK 11.267329
SGD 1.499148
SHP 0.923674
SLE 26.387427
SLL 24647.394644
SOS 671.734839
SRD 43.706933
STD 24328.248985
SVC 10.286415
SYP 15282.193175
SZL 20.651192
THB 38.137375
TJS 11.397089
TMT 4.125627
TND 3.393944
TOP 2.752882
TRY 46.813128
TTD 7.964994
TWD 33.982356
TZS 3093.090911
UAH 49.085437
UGX 4217.230841
USD 1.175392
UYU 47.096232
UZS 14815.821182
VES 128.674315
VND 30795.280137
VUV 139.81187
WST 3.05782
XAF 653.822286
XAG 0.031909
XAU 0.000353
XCD 3.176556
XDR 0.812649
XOF 654.071261
XPF 119.331742
YER 284.621858
ZAR 20.587109
ZMK 10579.940853
ZMW 28.360404
ZWL 378.475864
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%

TotalEnergies in landmark greenwashing trial in France
TotalEnergies in landmark greenwashing trial in France / Photo: LOIC VENANCE - AFP/File

TotalEnergies in landmark greenwashing trial in France

Environmental groups took TotalEnergies to court Thursday in a landmark Paris trial, accusing the French oil and gas giant of misleading consumers with ads that overstate its climate commitments and fossil fuel transition.

Text size:

It is the first such case in France targeting a major energy company and could set a legal precedent for corporate environmental advertising, which is starting to face tighter regulations in the European Union.

The civil case stems from a March 2022 lawsuit by three environmental groups accusing TotalEnergies of "misleading commercial practices" for saying it could reach carbon neutrality while continuing oil and gas production.

The plaintiffs took that legal route as "greenwashing", or the act of claiming to be more environmentally responsible than in reality, is not specifically covered under French law.

Starting in May 2021, TotalEnergies advertised its goal of "carbon neutrality by 2050" and touted gas as "the fossil fuel with the lowest greenhouse gas emissions".

At the time, the company had changed its name from Total to TotalEnergies to emphasise its investments in wind turbines and solar panels for electricity production.

The plaintiffs allege that TotalEnergies made around 40 "false advertisements" in their lawsuit.

"For the average consumer, it is impossible to understand that TotalEnergies is actually expanding fossil fuel production," said Clementine Baldon, a lawyer for the NGOs.

The company's strategy "will not help the energy transition", Baldon told the court.

"It delays it, even prevents it, and it contributes to putting the objectives of the Paris accord at risk," she added, referring to the international agreement aimed at curbing climate change.

TotalEnergies maintains it has not engaged in misleading commercial practices.

Moreover, it insists that the messages are part of its institutional communications regulated by financial authorities and not consumer law.

It has also argued the NGOs are misusing consumer protection rules to challenge its corporate strategy, and that no consumer organisation is party to the case.

The NGOs said the Paris court will rule on the legality of ads presenting natural gas as essential to the energy transition.

Climate experts say methane leaks from the gas industry have a powerful warming effect on the atmosphere.

- Correcting ads -

Environmental groups in recent years have turned to the courts to establish case law on companies misleading consumers by appearing more eco-friendly than they are.

In Europe, courts ruled against Dutch airline KLM in 2024 and Germany's Lufthansa in March over misleading consumers about their efforts to reduce the environmental impact of flying.

In Spain, utility Iberdrola failed to secure a conviction against Spanish oil and gas company Repsol over similar allegations of "false" environmental claims.

A greenwashing case against Australian oil and gas producer Santos, challenging its claim to be a "clean fuels" company, has been ongoing since 2021.

Other fossil fuel companies, under pressure from advertising regulators or legal complains, have had to scrap or correct ad campaigns.

Shell, for example, received a warning in the UK and had to stop promoting "carbon-neutral" gasoline in several countries, including Germany, the Netherlands and Canada.

New European laws now ban vague, generic environmental claims such as "green" or "100 percent natural" product, and aim to require brands to more strictly substantiate environmental claims on labels and in advertising.

TotalEnergies has said it plans to show that its messages "about its name change, strategy and role in the energy transition are reliable and based on objective, verifiable data".

(K.Müller--BBZ)