Berliner Boersenzeitung - Milei's dilemma: how to solve a problem like Argentina?

EUR -
AED 3.97801
AFN 75.110378
ALL 101.574566
AMD 436.535343
ANG 1.952113
AOA 897.781824
ARS 393.23902
AUD 1.648637
AWG 1.949856
AZN 1.842054
BAM 1.958138
BBD 2.187032
BDT 119.152272
BGN 1.958479
BHD 0.408417
BIF 3081.478959
BMD 1.083253
BND 1.450746
BOB 7.485179
BRL 5.349324
BSD 1.083203
BTN 90.240166
BWP 14.757097
BYN 3.568093
BYR 21231.76749
BZD 2.183378
CAD 1.469411
CDF 2892.286819
CHF 0.946303
CLF 0.034193
CLP 943.481442
CNY 7.735726
COP 4355.48045
CRC 571.677326
CUC 1.083253
CUP 28.706216
CVE 110.396818
CZK 24.317742
DJF 192.8585
DKK 7.456331
DOP 61.602987
DZD 145.571748
EGP 33.368213
ERN 16.248802
ETB 60.367824
FJD 2.42562
FKP 0.857669
GBP 0.856907
GEL 2.924235
GGP 0.857669
GHS 12.987928
GIP 0.857669
GMD 72.9842
GNF 9308.114222
GTQ 8.481048
GYD 226.617912
HKD 8.468561
HNL 26.727914
HRK 7.627805
HTG 143.271071
HUF 379.079116
IDR 16747.80235
ILS 4.030571
IMP 0.857669
INR 90.280943
IQD 1418.99433
IRR 45780.98414
ISK 150.712655
JEP 0.857669
JMD 167.986009
JOD 0.768463
JPY 158.996682
KES 166.117339
KGS 96.750454
KHR 4454.421541
KMF 490.11763
KPW 974.90502
KRW 1422.550293
KWD 0.334466
KYD 0.902707
KZT 499.542612
LAK 22435.581775
LBP 16280.565604
LKR 355.375814
LRD 203.814259
LSL 20.159048
LTL 3.198565
LVL 0.655249
LYD 5.223237
MAD 10.943465
MDL 19.172512
MGA 4951.866994
MKD 61.693664
MMK 2274.689556
MNT 3740.918024
MOP 8.722497
MRO 386.721293
MUR 47.944572
MVR 16.63849
MWK 1823.436163
MXN 18.896966
MYR 5.051751
MZN 68.515726
NAD 20.158827
NGN 868.769044
NIO 39.64734
NOK 11.768926
NPR 144.384065
NZD 1.762318
OMR 0.417096
PAB 1.083228
PEN 4.064315
PGK 4.09181
PHP 59.934787
PKR 308.158508
PLN 4.318449
PYG 8008.488492
QAR 3.943855
RON 4.967152
RSD 117.391253
RUB 100.079074
RWF 1348.754039
SAR 4.063021
SBD 9.181598
SCR 14.754165
SDG 651.035428
SEK 11.312274
SGD 1.449859
SHP 1.318049
SLE 24.519748
SLL 21394.254954
SOS 619.079099
SRD 40.946461
STD 22421.159198
SYP 14084.30004
SZL 20.462094
THB 38.106149
TJS 11.844333
TMT 3.791387
TND 3.372127
TOP 2.555015
TRY 31.325951
TTD 7.339696
TWD 34.146102
TZS 2708.133517
UAH 39.74414
UGX 4110.946567
USD 1.083253
UYU 42.230425
UZS 13311.894879
VEF 3849544.35115
VES 38.494656
VND 26291.644325
VUV 129.114914
WST 2.946402
XAF 656.756348
XAG 0.044699
XAU 0.000536
XCD 2.927547
XDR 0.812778
XOF 656.741172
XPF 118.99507
YER 271.192662
ZAR 20.506527
ZMK 9750.576497
ZMW 25.968768
ZWL 348.807167
  • RBGPF

    -0.4940

    67.542

    -0.73%

  • SCU

    -0.0300

    12.72

    -0.24%

  • SLAC

    0.0000

    10.31

    0%

  • CMSC

    0.0900

    24.57

    +0.37%

  • CMSD

    0.1400

    24.19

    +0.58%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0405

    3.596

    -1.13%

  • RELX

    0.1650

    38.755

    +0.43%

  • NGG

    0.0500

    66.26

    +0.08%

  • SCS

    -0.0720

    12.368

    -0.58%

  • GSK

    -0.2800

    36.35

    -0.77%

  • JRI

    -0.0700

    11.25

    -0.62%

  • RIO

    -0.3650

    68.685

    -0.53%

  • BCC

    -0.7700

    113.8

    -0.68%

  • VOD

    0.0000

    9.04

    0%

  • BCE

    0.0350

    40.635

    +0.09%

  • AZN

    -0.7400

    64.28

    -1.15%

  • BP

    -0.0850

    35.505

    -0.24%

  • BTI

    -0.3650

    31.565

    -1.16%

Milei's dilemma: how to solve a problem like Argentina?
Milei's dilemma: how to solve a problem like Argentina? / Photo: Luis ROBAYO - AFP

Milei's dilemma: how to solve a problem like Argentina?

Argentina's president-elect Javier Milei will have no time to bask in his Sunday victory as he inherits a country crippled by inflation and short on cash, creditors and international sympathy.

Text size:

"Being president of Argentina has got to be one of the worst jobs in politics in the world," said Benjamin Gedan, director of the Argentina Project at the Washington-based Wilson Center.

"The problems have become so deep and complex and intertwined that they're not easily solvable, even if they're easily identifiable."

Milei surged to power on a wave of anger over decades of economic mismanagement, vowing to ditch the peso for the US dollar, shut down the central bank and slash spending.

He has promised "the end of Argentina's decline" and warned there is no time for "gradualism... or half-measures."

He will take office on December 10, and analysts predict a rocky ride with inflation at 143 percent and poverty levels of over 40 percent.

- How and when will he dollarize the economy? -

Milei has proposed the dollarization of the economy by 2025 to halt the "cancer of inflation", meaning he would drop the peso and Argentina would lose control over monetary policy such as setting interest rates.

Dollarization requires a hefty stock of greenbacks, and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has warned Argentina's dollar reserves are dangerously low.

Even with the backing of the center-right opposition, political newcomer Milei has "very little legislative power," said analyst Carlos Gervasoni of the Torcuato Di Tella University.

"So there is no way to pass laws that, for example, require changing the country's currency or closing the central bank."

- What will happen with the peso? -

To try and keep a lid on inflation, the Argentine government has for years strictly controlled the exchange rate of the peso to the dollar, which was frozen for three months before the election and is now being allowed to devalue at three percent per month.

The exchange rate is "a total fiction. And to maintain it is extremely expensive. Argentina just has literally no money. It can't continue doing this," said Nicolas Saldias, a senior analyst with the Economist Intelligence Unit.

Between now and when Milei takes office, "things could rapidly scale out of control in those weeks. That's a period of a lot of instability," said political analyst Ana Iparraguirre of GBAO Strategies.

Saldias said people may panic believing dollarization is imminent, sparking a run on the peso.

Economy Minister Sergio Massa, whom Milei beat in Sunday's polls, may also implement a long overdue devaluation of the peso, making Milei "pay the political price."

"You'll probably see inflation ramp up very quickly," said Saldias, warning of possible hyperinflation.

- Will Milei take a chainsaw to state spending? -

Milei often appeared on stage at rallies with a chainsaw, vowing to slash public spending by 15 percent, privatize state companies and reduce subsidies on fuel, transport and electricity.

Such belt tightening has long been demanded by the IMF, which has bailed out Argentina 22 times, most recently with a loan of $44 billion dollars in 2018.

But Milei will face the same challenges as predecessors who have tried to get out of a vicious cycle of budget deficits, debt, money printing and inflation.

Untangling the country's economy is tricky. Removing subsidies or slashing welfare payouts would only further worsen poverty, and floating the currency would make imports much more expensive.

"At this point everything you fix worsens a second problem," Gedan said.

"The pain will be acute and spread widely if there is a serious stabilization program and it's not clear that Argentines will see the upside."

There is also the danger of protests and social unrest, especially given that almost half the country did not want Milei in power.

- Is there any good news? -

Gedan said that if Milei and his allies in the opposition do manage to curtail spending and reduce welfare and subsidies while protecting the most vulnerable, "this could be a turning point for the good."

There are other positives on the horizon.

After Argentina's worst drought in a century, which saw agricultural exports plummet in the past two years leading to a $20 billion shortfall in revenue, the country is expecting a bumper harvest in 2024.

Milei will also benefit from an estimated $10 billion in annual savings in energy imports as a new gas pipeline ramps up production from southern Vaca Muerta -- a massive oil and gas reserve -- estimates economist Elizabeth Bacigalupo of the Abeceb firm.

(O.Joost--BBZ)