Berliner Boersenzeitung - Indonesian families face grief, intimidation year after stadium crush

EUR -
AED 4.061239
AFN 70.774285
ALL 90.674324
AMD 400.588378
ANG 1.979985
AOA 1014.065922
ARS 1708.818725
AUD 1.627461
AWG 1.992192
AZN 1.879823
BAM 1.955229
BBD 2.233478
BDT 137.929696
BGN 1.9559
BHD 0.418387
BIF 3352.91121
BMD 1.105852
BND 1.425122
BOB 12.980207
BRL 6.24054
BSD 1.108886
BTN 104.234956
BWP 15.384644
BYN 3.340924
BYR 21674.696468
BZD 2.230279
CAD 1.577039
CDF 2560.046784
CHF 0.924354
CLF 0.027949
CLP 1099.98486
CNY 7.37675
CNH 7.377757
COP 3668.807308
CRC 500.66502
CUC 1.105852
CUP 26.614223
CVE 110.234284
CZK 24.380825
DJF 197.474975
DKK 7.475371
DOP 67.280948
DZD 151.457624
EGP 59.092272
ERN 16.587778
ETB 181.067828
FJD 2.515094
FKP 0.835271
GBP 0.836107
GEL 2.864315
GGP 0.835271
GHS 12.985206
GIP 0.835271
GMD 81.832691
GNF 9825.217834
GTQ 8.473639
GYD 232.002207
HKD 8.675264
HNL 29.819556
HRK 7.534784
HTG 145.301483
HUF 365.491779
IDR 20145.248052
ILS 3.540329
IMP 0.835271
INR 104.187335
IQD 1681.139161
IRR 2116047.535497
ISK 136.616819
JEP 0.835271
JMD 175.668668
JOD 0.784015
JPY 176.996042
KES 143.716444
KGS 96.705527
KHR 4569.78864
KMF 493.210208
KPW 995.266721
KRW 1476.417309
KWD 0.34434
KYD 0.924147
KZT 492.534985
LAK 24954.70802
LBP 99304.282436
LKR 368.772242
LRD 188.517471
LSL 18.550659
LTL 3.265293
LVL 0.668919
LYD 7.151007
MAD 10.922908
MDL 20.227089
MGA 5061.52098
MKD 61.54566
MMK 2322.178184
MNT 3985.580384
MOP 8.959244
MRU 44.869968
MUR 52.660715
MVR 17.041092
MWK 1920.864311
MXN 20.579351
MYR 4.518954
MZN 70.674713
NAD 18.53394
NGN 1486.587678
NIO 40.808444
NOK 10.583743
NPR 166.774775
NZD 1.995747
OMR 0.425205
PAB 1.108976
PEN 3.780995
PGK 5.058613
PHP 70.551412
PKR 306.648568
PLN 4.405067
PYG 6874.084575
QAR 4.042474
RON 5.346681
RSD 117.602261
RUB 91.561274
RWF 1638.121327
SAR 4.174609
SBD 8.954413
SCR 15.490166
SDG 665.172606
SEK 11.089316
SGD 1.423286
SHP 0.828633
SLE 25.323544
SLL 23189.184907
SOS 633.101178
SRD 41.473866
STD 22888.900808
STN 24.493286
SVC 9.70334
SYP 14378.286141
SZL 18.534317
THB 37.444695
TJS 10.229949
TMT 3.88154
TND 3.33797
TOP 2.662625
TRY 55.680198
TTD 7.532935
TWD 36.35543
TZS 2940.298651
UAH 50.390575
UGX 4563.666457
USD 1.105852
UYU 44.947069
UZS 13274.121188
VES 995.809091
VND 28391.087743
VUV 133.070168
WST 3.0907
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.022146
XAU 0.000283734004
XCD 2.98862
XCG 1.998552
XDR 0.781895
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 261.535134
ZAR 18.548679
ZMK 9953.992832
ZMW 22.649689
ZWL 356.083848
SSP 6575.959858
MXV 2.311087
  • CMSD

    -0.1200

    19.81

    -0.61%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

  • BCC

    -1.8200

    74.15

    -2.45%

  • CMSC

    -0.2228

    19.53

    -1.14%

  • BCE

    0.2000

    20.34

    +0.98%

  • RIO

    0.0100

    94.17

    +0.01%

  • AZN

    -2.7400

    161.47

    -1.7%

  • GSK

    -1.1800

    48.17

    -2.45%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    65

    0%

  • NGG

    0.8800

    75.82

    +1.16%

  • RYCEF

    -0.7300

    19.08

    -3.83%

  • BTI

    -0.4500

    54.4

    -0.83%

  • BP

    0.4700

    43.99

    +1.07%

  • RELX

    -0.0600

    33.18

    -0.18%

  • VOD

    -0.1800

    16.15

    -1.11%

Indonesian families face grief, intimidation year after stadium crush
Indonesian families face grief, intimidation year after stadium crush / Photo: Juni Kriswanto - AFP

Indonesian families face grief, intimidation year after stadium crush

Holding buckets of water, Cholifatul Nur sprinkles flowers planted at her young son's grave and wipes clean the stone slab where a scarf of his favourite team is draped a year after his death at an Indonesian football stadium.

Text size:

Fifteen-year-old Jovan Farellino was one of 135 people killed after a match in the East Javan city of Malang, with many dying from suffocation or being trampled in one of the deadliest disasters in the sport's history.

Wearing all black, Nur speaks of the grief and intimidation she has faced in her fight for justice alongside other relatives of the dead. They blame police who fired tear gas into stands packed with Arema FC fans, causing a panicked rush for small exits.

"Jovan was everything for me. He was my only child," she told AFP.

She rushed to the stadium just before midnight after hearing about the unfolding tragedy, knowing her son had attended, only the third time he had done so.

When she arrived, she found his lifeless body at the VIP gate where his friends had moved him.

"Suddenly he perished in that way. I can't accept that," she said.

The tear gas shot into stands after a post-match pitch invasion was deemed the official cause of the deaths, but families say authorities have not been held appropriately responsible for their actions at Kanjuruhan Stadium.

Several prison sentences have been handed to three police officers for negligence, ranging from one to two-and-a-half years.

Two of them were acquitted earlier this year, to families' dismay, but the Supreme Court has since overturned that decision.

A judge also earlier ruled police had not shot tear gas into stands -- rather it was carried by the wind. But that account was disputed by witnesses and challenged by video footage. FIFA, football's world governing body, bans the use of tear gas in stadiums.

Seven families, including Nur's, pursued legal action seeking compensation of around 62 billion rupiah ($4 million), according to Imam Hidayat, a lawyer representing them. But a local court rejected that bid.

- 'Life for a life' -

The tragedy stoked the ire of Indonesians against the country's police, who critics have long accused of using excessive violence to quell unrest as well as intimidation to silence detractors.

After criticising authorities during police questioning, Nur says men in black clothing nearly hit her on a motorbike. She also caught people taking photographs of her home.

Nur says police officers even told her they could help her nephew join the force.

"I don't want that. The child I lost came from my own womb," she told AFP.

"I want the death sentence (for the officers). It's fair, a life for a life."

Rini Hanifah lost her 20-year-old son, Agus Riansyah, in the stadium crush after he had asked for her permission to attend the match.

She allowed Agus to go but refused to let him take two younger siblings because, even with away fans banned, it was a heated derby against fierce rivals Persebaya Surabaya.

The mother, who says she is seeing a psychiatrist to deal with the grief, claims she was also offered the opportunity for her other children to join the police force.

"They told me if my children wanted to become police officers, it would be easy," she said.

East Java police did not respond to an AFP request for comment.

Indonesian football association executive committee member Srya Sinulingga said officials have "made various changes, both reactive to events and proactive" including improved stadium safety measures.

But many believe the police have not, like Hanifah, who called police "scoundrels" and slammed the trial.

"It was a sham. It felt like a puppet show," she said.

"Please, restore our trust, so that we believe again that in Indonesia there is justice."

- 'Have to fight' -

Survivors recounted the horrors they witnessed and the trauma they still face a year later.

Dayangga Sola Gratia, a 23-year-old water park worker in Malang, is on medication to help her deal with what she saw.

"Since then, I never look at football, I don't even look at notifications (about it). I immediately erase them," she said.

She feels anger towards the people she says have not been held accountable.

"Let them feel what we felt at the time. Let's swap," she said.

"After this (sentence) they are free, they can still gather with their family, but can those who were left behind?"

That rage mixed with grief has hardened relatives' resolve.

Families visited the country's criminal investigation department this week to lobby for a new probe, submitting a report that calls for officers to be charged with murder, premeditated murder and violence against children.

The maximum sentence for non-premeditated murder in Indonesia is 15 years in prison. Murder is punishable by death.

"We support the families' fight for justice," said Usman Hamid of Amnesty International Indonesia, adding no significant government measures have been taken to prevent a repeat disaster.

Back in Malang, Nur kisses a prayer book before leaving her son's grave, wipes away tears and makes him a promise that she will avenge his death.

"This is my child. I have to fight for him... I have to find justice, whatever's at stake," she said.

"If my life could be exchanged with justice, I want that."

(H.Schneide--BBZ)