Berliner Boersenzeitung - Cheap drones 'cannot match' artillery power in Ukraine: experts

EUR -
AED 4.26981
AFN 79.430376
ALL 97.075055
AMD 446.133867
ANG 2.080488
AOA 1065.993588
ARS 1540.886156
AUD 1.786016
AWG 2.095369
AZN 1.972862
BAM 1.952834
BBD 2.348194
BDT 141.295382
BGN 1.952615
BHD 0.438255
BIF 3467.921964
BMD 1.162479
BND 1.494269
BOB 8.064958
BRL 6.329931
BSD 1.162949
BTN 101.928685
BWP 15.647636
BYN 3.829782
BYR 22784.593786
BZD 2.336112
CAD 1.602437
CDF 3359.565284
CHF 0.942889
CLF 0.028728
CLP 1127.000161
CNY 8.348348
CNH 8.361138
COP 4709.098919
CRC 588.114284
CUC 1.162479
CUP 30.805701
CVE 110.101079
CZK 24.478909
DJF 207.100773
DKK 7.462919
DOP 71.033938
DZD 151.087115
EGP 56.3685
ERN 17.437189
ETB 162.138108
FJD 2.623014
FKP 0.864403
GBP 0.865646
GEL 3.140866
GGP 0.864403
GHS 12.26968
GIP 0.864403
GMD 84.27863
GNF 10084.682069
GTQ 8.922677
GYD 243.256788
HKD 9.12541
HNL 30.503667
HRK 7.532752
HTG 152.290646
HUF 395.799775
IDR 18938.763601
ILS 3.972779
IMP 0.864403
INR 101.984654
IQD 1523.525189
IRR 48969.440014
ISK 143.019733
JEP 0.864403
JMD 186.197179
JOD 0.82424
JPY 171.956843
KES 150.193483
KGS 101.633584
KHR 4657.046454
KMF 490.740698
KPW 1046.231142
KRW 1617.926605
KWD 0.355373
KYD 0.969153
KZT 631.861987
LAK 25156.438329
LBP 104202.612624
LKR 349.763247
LRD 233.171846
LSL 20.616018
LTL 3.432499
LVL 0.703172
LYD 6.305423
MAD 10.510935
MDL 19.50288
MGA 5131.338278
MKD 61.446667
MMK 2440.367499
MNT 4177.563951
MOP 9.403559
MRU 46.366572
MUR 52.75303
MVR 17.904737
MWK 2016.588983
MXN 21.646085
MYR 4.921356
MZN 74.352946
NAD 20.615487
NGN 1782.999126
NIO 42.794997
NOK 11.907252
NPR 163.082394
NZD 1.960171
OMR 0.446962
PAB 1.162964
PEN 4.097077
PGK 4.905675
PHP 66.308399
PKR 330.135607
PLN 4.254151
PYG 8710.768948
QAR 4.240659
RON 5.064692
RSD 117.17097
RUB 92.561569
RWF 1682.787391
SAR 4.362653
SBD 9.552168
SCR 17.137387
SDG 698.068432
SEK 11.183126
SGD 1.495635
SHP 0.913526
SLE 26.857073
SLL 24376.613741
SOS 664.607659
SRD 43.336073
STD 24060.973952
STN 24.463158
SVC 10.175588
SYP 15114.290017
SZL 20.620389
THB 37.700943
TJS 10.833125
TMT 4.080302
TND 3.408722
TOP 2.722647
TRY 47.317313
TTD 7.893214
TWD 34.770932
TZS 2923.63532
UAH 48.224181
UGX 4143.705999
USD 1.162479
UYU 46.579249
UZS 14737.614588
VES 149.666591
VND 30495.318816
VUV 138.801361
WST 3.085123
XAF 654.979035
XAG 0.030766
XAU 0.000346
XCD 3.141658
XCG 2.095988
XDR 0.814248
XOF 654.981848
XPF 119.331742
YER 279.518465
ZAR 20.653862
ZMK 10463.711932
ZMW 27.039626
ZWL 374.317852
  • SCU

    0.0000

    12.72

    0%

  • RBGPF

    4.1600

    76

    +5.47%

  • NGG

    0.1530

    71.163

    +0.21%

  • SCS

    -0.0450

    15.835

    -0.28%

  • CMSD

    -0.0320

    23.548

    -0.14%

  • RIO

    -0.0460

    61.814

    -0.07%

  • CMSC

    0.0400

    23.09

    +0.17%

  • JRI

    -0.0150

    13.42

    -0.11%

  • BCC

    -1.9200

    80.17

    -2.39%

  • GSK

    -0.0550

    37.745

    -0.15%

  • BTI

    0.9150

    58.155

    +1.57%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0100

    14.34

    -0.07%

  • RELX

    -0.0900

    47.91

    -0.19%

  • BCE

    0.1500

    24.5

    +0.61%

  • VOD

    0.1300

    11.49

    +1.13%

  • AZN

    0.1600

    73.695

    +0.22%

  • BP

    -0.2350

    33.905

    -0.69%

Cheap drones 'cannot match' artillery power in Ukraine: experts
Cheap drones 'cannot match' artillery power in Ukraine: experts / Photo: Genya SAVILOV - AFP/File

Cheap drones 'cannot match' artillery power in Ukraine: experts

Ukraine is relying on the massive use of drones to compensate for an artillery shell shortage and undermine Russian military capabilities, but experts warned they cannot tip the balance.

Text size:

Both drones used for strikes hundreds of kilometres away and commercial drones are starting to dominate the battlefield.

In particular, so-called First Person View (FPV) drones allow their pilots to see live images of the ground as if they were on board and can locate enemy units and, if armed with explosives, attack them from within a few kilometres.

"At the moment in Ukraine, we are seeing the use of drones on an unimaginable scale, we are really talking about tens and hundreds of thousands of drones on the battlefield," Ulrike Franke, a researcher at the European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR), told AFP.

In its 2024 budget Kyiv earmarked 1.15 billion euros ($1.25 billion) for drones, and President Volodymyr Zelensky announced that the country will produce "one million drones" this year, after setting up a specific drone branch in February.

Kyiv's direction comes as its supporters are trying to bolster Ukrainian stocks -- London is set to deliver more than 10,000 drones, of which one thousand are FPV drones, and Paris is preparing to order 2,000 kamikaze drones, some of which will be used in Ukraine.

Ukrainian officials estimate between 100,000 and 120,000 drones are needed monthly.

Whereas it needs 200,000 to 250,000 artillery shells per month for a major offensive or 75,000 to 90,000 to sustain the war defensively, according to an Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) review.

Western backers largely depend on US stocks to sustain defence, but Kyiv does not have enough ammunition to launch a major offensive next year, it added.

So "Ukraine can reduce its requirements for artillery ammunition by significantly increasing production of strike drones" continued Michael Kofman and Franz-Stefan Gady in the IISS review.

Drones are "capable of reproducing many of the functions of artillery and missiles at a fraction of the cost", agreed Mykola Bielieskov of the Atlantic Council.

A small commercial drone costs just a few hundred euros, whereas a simple anti-tank missile, artillery shell or remotely operated munition costs several thousands.

- "Not ideal" -

Ukrainian FPV drones are currently responsible for between 65 and 85 percent of the destruction of Russian positions, according to a French military source.

But Ulrike Franke warned: "They use drones because they can produce or buy them, but it is not ideal."

FPV drones have a small load capacity of just hundreds of grams of explosive and a few kilograms for the largest commercial drones.

"Even large numbers of small drones cannot match the potency of artillery fire," agreed Stacie Pettyjohn in a study by American security think-tank "CNAS".

Drones can supplement indirect fire weapons, but they are not substitutes, she added.

In September, the New York Times reported that less than a third of drone strikes hit their target, as the machines can easily be jammed or disrupted by electronic countermeasures.

Ukraine can no longer count on superiority in the field of drones.

In 2022 Ukraine had a "9-to-1 advantage" in commercial drones but this lead has now "essential disappeared", Pettyjohn added.

"While the Russian Ministry of Defence was slow to catch up, Russian troops had quickly realized the utility of commercial quadcopters and volunteer groups had emerged to provide frontline soldiers with drones and the necessary training."

Russia also relied heavily on FPV kamikaze drones to thwart Ukraine’s counter-offensive last summer.

For Pettyjohn, although drones offer new capabilities, they ultimately make it more difficult to "concentrate forces, achieve surprise, and conduct offensive operations" so they will not make "truly disruptive change".

burs-mra/tq/ico/spb/cw

(T.Renner--BBZ)