Berliner Boersenzeitung - Trump’s Ukraine Economic Colony Plan Stirs Debate

EUR -
AED 4.274818
AFN 80.306541
ALL 97.240019
AMD 446.875897
ANG 2.082959
AOA 1067.259829
ARS 1468.196782
AUD 1.78422
AWG 2.094948
AZN 1.978956
BAM 1.959791
BBD 2.350486
BDT 141.207538
BGN 1.952945
BHD 0.438796
BIF 3405.454207
BMD 1.16386
BND 1.495339
BOB 8.04445
BRL 6.46268
BSD 1.16407
BTN 100.01523
BWP 15.72322
BYN 3.809658
BYR 22811.654978
BZD 2.338382
CAD 1.594308
CDF 3358.900146
CHF 0.931711
CLF 0.029337
CLP 1125.7784
CNY 8.348318
CNH 8.355252
COP 4674.061551
CRC 587.393576
CUC 1.16386
CUP 30.842289
CVE 111.206859
CZK 24.647876
DJF 206.841435
DKK 7.463584
DOP 70.163317
DZD 151.511194
EGP 57.510044
ERN 17.457899
ETB 158.925196
FJD 2.622529
FKP 0.868904
GBP 0.867481
GEL 3.154216
GGP 0.868904
GHS 12.106869
GIP 0.868904
GMD 83.211504
GNF 10074.371387
GTQ 8.932188
GYD 243.548025
HKD 9.136266
HNL 30.667827
HRK 7.533674
HTG 152.851248
HUF 399.517034
IDR 18979.064169
ILS 3.910866
IMP 0.868904
INR 99.951303
IQD 1524.656532
IRR 49027.599692
ISK 142.119157
JEP 0.868904
JMD 186.149052
JOD 0.82517
JPY 171.944596
KES 150.713635
KGS 101.77994
KHR 4678.717067
KMF 494.204001
KPW 1047.533912
KRW 1613.69044
KWD 0.355594
KYD 0.970088
KZT 613.937513
LAK 25098.639435
LBP 104223.65863
LKR 351.044826
LRD 233.93589
LSL 20.867839
LTL 3.436576
LVL 0.704007
LYD 6.296726
MAD 10.546314
MDL 19.766505
MGA 5155.899943
MKD 61.685609
MMK 2443.040881
MNT 4174.42453
MOP 9.412748
MRU 46.228082
MUR 52.966978
MVR 17.925753
MWK 2021.044303
MXN 21.80047
MYR 4.940592
MZN 74.440892
NAD 20.868436
NGN 1780.623871
NIO 42.77219
NOK 11.926771
NPR 160.024856
NZD 1.958503
OMR 0.447504
PAB 1.16408
PEN 4.136328
PGK 4.810524
PHP 66.334185
PKR 331.292637
PLN 4.257043
PYG 9014.355776
QAR 4.23715
RON 5.071874
RSD 117.143657
RUB 91.069694
RWF 1671.884815
SAR 4.36548
SBD 9.682802
SCR 16.934503
SDG 698.895897
SEK 11.3172
SGD 1.493181
SHP 0.914611
SLE 26.128825
SLL 24405.56577
SOS 665.143965
SRD 43.206559
STD 24089.551096
SVC 10.185741
SYP 15132.368948
SZL 20.867995
THB 37.755932
TJS 11.146393
TMT 4.085148
TND 3.378104
TOP 2.725874
TRY 46.843937
TTD 7.899051
TWD 34.158163
TZS 3043.493495
UAH 48.747993
UGX 4171.494342
USD 1.16386
UYU 47.08588
UZS 14891.58781
VES 135.967975
VND 30446.576236
VUV 138.992047
WST 3.204456
XAF 657.29261
XAG 0.030704
XAU 0.000347
XCD 3.14539
XDR 0.817968
XOF 654.08933
XPF 119.331742
YER 280.89754
ZAR 20.741834
ZMK 10476.135178
ZMW 26.542276
ZWL 374.762428
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%


Trump’s Ukraine Economic Colony Plan Stirs Debate




As the war in Ukraine continues to reshape global geopolitics, a contentious proposal from US President Donald Trump has ignited fierce debate. Reports emerging in early 2025 suggest that Trump is pushing a deal that would grant the United States significant control over Ukraine’s vast natural resources, effectively turning the war-torn nation into what critics are calling an "economic colony." This development, rooted in negotiations tied to US military and financial aid, has raised alarm bells in Kyiv and among European allies.

According to sources, including a detailed report by EurasiaTimes on 20 February 2025, Trump’s administration has proposed a contract that demands a 50% share of Ukraine’s revenue from its critical minerals, ports, infrastructure, oil, and gas reserves. This comes as a condition for continued US support, which has been vital to Ukraine’s defence against Russia’s invasion since February 2022. The proposed terms are staggering: the US claims it has provided $500 billion in aid—a figure disputed by independent estimates, such as the Kiel Institute for the World Economy, which pegs US contributions at approximately $119 billion as of late 2024. In return, Trump seeks economic dominance over Ukraine’s resources, estimated to be worth trillions of dollars.

Ukraine, despite occupying just 0.4% of the Earth’s surface, is a treasure trove of rare earth elements, titanium, lithium, and other minerals critical to modern technology and defence industries. However, much of this wealth remains untapped or lies in Russian-occupied territories, complicating extraction efforts. Trump’s plan, as outlined in a leaked document cited by The Telegraph on 7 February 2025, includes establishing a "joint investment fund" to ensure that "hostile conflict parties"—namely Russia and potentially China—do not benefit from Ukraine’s reconstruction. The deal also reportedly grants the US "investment screening" powers, allowing Washington to dictate Ukraine’s economic partnerships.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has expressed unease, rejecting an initial draft in February 2025 that lacked security guarantees. "It is very important that there is a connection between security guarantees and a form of investment," Zelensky said, as reported by NBC News on 19 February 2025. His hesitation reflects a broader concern: that accepting Trump’s terms could lock Ukraine into a perpetual state of economic subservience, reminiscent of colonial arrangements imposed on defeated nations after major wars. Ukrainian economist Roman Sheremeta described the proposal as "effectively turning Ukraine into an American colony," a sentiment echoed across social media platforms like X, where users have labelled it "economic colonisation."

The plan has drawn sharp criticism internationally. German Chancellor Olaf Scholz called it "egoistic" during an EU summit on 4 February 2025, arguing that Ukraine’s resources should fund its own rebuilding, not serve foreign interests. European leaders fear being sidelined, especially as Trump has pursued direct talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin—most recently on 19 March 2025—without consulting NATO allies. These negotiations, held in Saudi Arabia, have fuelled speculation that Trump might trade Ukrainian sovereignty for a swift resolution to the conflict, a move that could bolster his domestic image ahead of the 2026 midterms.

Trump defends his approach, framing it as a pragmatic exchange. "We’ve given them hundreds of billions, and they’ve got great rare earths," he said on 4 February 2025, per Newspapers. He has also threatened to halt US military aid—paused since 3 March 2025—unless Zelensky complies, a stance that has deepened tensions following a public spat in the White House in late February. Yet, the numbers don’t fully align with Trump’s rhetoric: the Center for Strategic & International Studies estimates total US aid at $174.2 billion, far below the $350 billion he has claimed.

For Ukraine, the stakes are existential. Accepting the deal could secure short-term survival but at the cost of long-term autonomy. Rejecting it risks losing US support, potentially forcing Kyiv to cede ground to Russia. As of now, no agreement has been signed, but pressure is mounting. On 31 March 2025, Trump warned Zelensky of "big problems" if he backs out, according to ZDFheute. With Putin tying any ceasefire to Russian gains in Kursk, as noted by morgenpost.de on 7 March 2025, Ukraine finds itself caught between two superpowers, its future hanging in the balance.