Berliner Boersenzeitung - Brazil's Porto Alegre: a flood disaster waiting to happen

EUR -
AED 3.977664
AFN 77.818796
ALL 100.136903
AMD 419.727277
ANG 1.951811
AOA 918.724306
ARS 964.120714
AUD 1.633841
AWG 1.952004
AZN 1.838987
BAM 1.953009
BBD 2.186675
BDT 127.028475
BGN 1.954491
BHD 0.408259
BIF 3108.557833
BMD 1.082942
BND 1.461312
BOB 7.483306
BRL 5.578342
BSD 1.082952
BTN 90.129204
BWP 14.694002
BYN 3.544135
BYR 21225.672253
BZD 2.18298
CAD 1.482738
CDF 3032.238735
CHF 0.989788
CLF 0.035674
CLP 984.318978
CNY 7.846357
CNH 7.860865
COP 4150.160397
CRC 555.30646
CUC 1.082942
CUP 28.697975
CVE 110.107655
CZK 24.727886
DJF 192.824451
DKK 7.461983
DOP 63.65903
DZD 145.812268
EGP 51.058244
ERN 16.244137
ETB 62.222883
FJD 2.454053
FKP 0.862129
GBP 0.85181
GEL 2.945742
GGP 0.862129
GHS 15.757482
GIP 0.862129
GMD 73.368923
GNF 9309.696329
GTQ 8.414975
GYD 226.696049
HKD 8.456941
HNL 26.764753
HRK 7.558891
HTG 144.034173
HUF 386.967954
IDR 17405.75516
ILS 3.978568
IMP 0.862129
INR 90.198657
IQD 1418.672699
IRR 45551.265612
ISK 150.107117
JEP 0.862129
JMD 169.098356
JOD 0.7677
JPY 170.109643
KES 143.760914
KGS 95.293416
KHR 4415.689925
KMF 492.576335
KPW 974.647888
KRW 1479.657025
KWD 0.332453
KYD 0.90251
KZT 479.794368
LAK 23155.90992
LBP 96980.613509
LKR 325.005563
LRD 209.630603
LSL 19.806775
LTL 3.197648
LVL 0.655061
LYD 5.240511
MAD 10.772107
MDL 19.146639
MGA 4796.146248
MKD 61.438134
MMK 2274.250069
MNT 3736.151248
MOP 8.709254
MRU 43.025335
MUR 50.107408
MVR 16.731186
MWK 1877.71672
MXN 18.099683
MYR 5.094703
MZN 68.760578
NAD 19.807026
NGN 1563.76921
NIO 39.863035
NOK 11.537328
NPR 144.206927
NZD 1.771234
OMR 0.416748
PAB 1.082952
PEN 4.041924
PGK 4.208985
PHP 63.087357
PKR 301.392606
PLN 4.261269
PYG 8144.361607
QAR 3.943265
RON 4.976149
RSD 117.160251
RUB 97.68574
RWF 1424.064994
SAR 4.061665
SBD 9.205261
SCR 14.605571
SDG 650.848651
SEK 11.616025
SGD 1.463067
SHP 1.368243
SLE 24.742314
SLL 22708.762972
SOS 618.360121
SRD 34.953593
STD 22414.722509
SVC 9.476458
SYP 2720.925267
SZL 19.893572
THB 39.657326
TJS 11.663633
TMT 3.790299
TND 3.380402
TOP 2.561538
TRY 34.87718
TTD 7.349497
TWD 34.918717
TZS 2815.776016
UAH 43.261479
UGX 4142.080915
USD 1.082942
UYU 41.480724
UZS 13780.307771
VEF 3923015.959957
VES 39.528203
VND 27582.003033
VUV 128.569084
WST 3.035588
XAF 655.020967
XAG 0.035768
XAU 0.000462
XCD 2.926706
XDR 0.818131
XOF 655.020967
XPF 119.331742
YER 271.174654
ZAR 19.982992
ZMK 9747.785718
ZMW 28.672027
ZWL 348.707031
  • SCS

    -0.0700

    13.14

    -0.53%

  • CMSC

    -0.2830

    24.217

    -1.17%

  • CMSD

    -0.2130

    24.047

    -0.89%

  • BCC

    -0.0900

    136.76

    -0.07%

  • NGG

    -8.3600

    63.63

    -13.14%

  • JRI

    -0.0900

    11.42

    -0.79%

  • RBGPF

    1.3300

    57.61

    +2.31%

  • RIO

    -0.2250

    71.995

    -0.31%

  • BCE

    -0.2250

    33.925

    -0.66%

  • RYCEF

    0.1930

    5.613

    +3.44%

  • VOD

    -0.1100

    9.41

    -1.17%

  • RELX

    0.0850

    44.445

    +0.19%

  • BTI

    -0.3900

    30.97

    -1.26%

  • GSK

    -0.5850

    45.195

    -1.29%

  • BP

    0.1660

    36.726

    +0.45%

  • AZN

    0.2200

    79.02

    +0.28%

Brazil's Porto Alegre: a flood disaster waiting to happen
Brazil's Porto Alegre: a flood disaster waiting to happen / Photo: Anselmo Cunha - AFP

Brazil's Porto Alegre: a flood disaster waiting to happen

Porto Alegre, the Brazilian metropolis left submerged after torrential rains, had been lulled into a "false sense" of security by a vast but aging system of flood defenses, an urban drainage engineer told AFP.

Text size:

Leomar Teichmann said a network of dikes, levees and a massive wall was meant to protect about 40 percent of the capital city of Rio Grande do Sul state in southern Brazil, where 150 people have died and hundreds of thousands were forced from their homes.

Teichmann is an engineering consultant and former deputy director of water and sewerage services for Porto Alegre, a city of 1.4 million people on the banks of the Guaiba estuary.

He told AFP he had already warned in 2019 that the city was at risk.

- What does system consist of? -

"The system was designed after floods in 1967 and built in the 1970s. It includes about 65 kilometers (40 miles) of dykes and a concrete wall of 2.67 km, as well as 14 floodgates and 22 storm water pumping stations.

"It was a simple system that seemed functional, since it guaranteed the protection of the urbanized part of Porto Alegre.

"However, it was never tested in practice until November 2023, because it was only on this occasion that the level of the Jacui River exceeded three meters (10 feet), which is the level of the Maua wall," leading to flooding, he explained.

"In other words, the system stood for 51 years without the water of the Jacui River ever touching the wall."

- Why did it fail with latest floods? -

"Gate Number 14 buckled under the great pressure of the water and began to leak with great volume and speed.

"The amount of water was so great that the nearby pumping stations were quickly flooded, causing the pumps to shut down.

"The flooding caused by the gate failure was so rapid that the entire region was flooded in a few hours.

"This flood eventually caused a power outage in the flooded areas, and as a result, all the pumping stations north of the Gasometer Plant stopped working," he said, referring to an out-of-service power plant.

"There were several failures in sequence. In about 24 hours, the water level on either side of the system was exactly the same."

- What were consequences of these failures? -

"Already in 2019, I stated that the protection system installed in Porto Alegre gave the population a false sense of protection and security, because there was no way to contain water in case of failure of any of the elements that make up this system.

"It is an old system, with many points subject to failure and requiring high investments in operation and maintenance.

"Much is said about Porto Alegre, but this same type of flood protection system was built in Canoas, Sao Leopoldo and Novo Hamburgo (other municipalities in the state) where the system was also overwhelmed by the water level.

"In all these cities the water very quickly invaded areas that should have been protected and caused greater tragedies than if the system did not exist."

Teichmann explained that water spilling over the dikes moved much faster than rising river levels.

"I'm not saying that dikes are useless, but with a flood of this size, as soon as the dikes were overcome by water, the speed with which water passed to the other side of these was much higher than if the dikes did not exist."

(S.G.Stein--BBZ)