Berliner Boersenzeitung - Tata turmoil shines light on India succession woes

EUR -
AED 4.036787
AFN 70.900699
ALL 90.107811
AMD 396.741965
ANG 1.967995
AOA 1009.058022
ARS 1716.111274
AUD 1.639287
AWG 1.981292
AZN 1.874079
BAM 1.956577
BBD 2.214788
BDT 136.774283
BGN 1.949383
BHD 0.414967
BIF 3303.140996
BMD 1.099191
BND 1.418076
BOB 12.927248
BRL 6.455943
BSD 1.099591
BTN 102.519501
BWP 15.533518
BYN 3.28827
BYR 21544.14841
BZD 2.211688
CAD 1.572058
CDF 2511.652198
CHF 0.9275
CLF 0.028111
CLP 1106.379645
CNY 7.329186
CNH 7.335667
COP 3718.322161
CRC 492.27522
CUC 1.099191
CUP 26.392475
CVE 110.308779
CZK 24.424964
DJF 195.792972
DKK 7.474324
DOP 66.193561
DZD 150.655262
EGP 59.159239
ERN 16.487869
ETB 180.495277
FJD 2.512529
FKP 0.835803
GBP 0.836699
GEL 2.846381
GGP 0.835803
GHS 12.927248
GIP 0.835803
GMD 80.822536
GNF 9748.869117
GTQ 8.406992
GYD 229.960471
HKD 8.623787
HNL 29.560732
HRK 7.509636
HTG 144.178533
HUF 370.186176
IDR 20071.39702
ILS 3.615683
IMP 0.835803
INR 102.554708
IQD 1667.161661
IRR 2124917.492176
ISK 137.212037
JEP 0.835803
JMD 174.039072
JOD 0.779295
JPY 175.78431
KES 142.950068
KGS 96.124096
KHR 4474.49088
KMF 493.536751
KPW 989.272506
KRW 1460.253273
KWD 0.342848
KYD 0.916485
KZT 495.098746
LAK 24778.059301
LBP 98481.681212
LKR 366.020281
LRD 184.710539
LSL 18.944543
LTL 3.245626
LVL 0.66489
LYD 7.116825
MAD 10.93634
MDL 20.179468
MGA 4965.015678
MKD 61.491924
MMK 2308.083324
MNT 3957.983279
MOP 8.885663
MRU 44.855966
MUR 51.48591
MVR 16.92048
MWK 1906.518434
MXN 20.831218
MYR 4.522294
MZN 70.236225
NAD 18.945319
NGN 1485.017998
NIO 40.464403
NOK 10.673131
NPR 164.061605
NZD 1.992647
OMR 0.422635
PAB 1.099746
PEN 3.752236
PGK 4.946963
PHP 70.016297
PKR 303.968394
PLN 4.423222
PYG 6894.736373
QAR 3.997587
RON 5.348334
RSD 117.633295
RUB 90.166085
RWF 1627.58297
SAR 4.125787
SBD 8.944165
SCR 15.265241
SDG 661.154928
SEK 11.170575
SGD 1.418094
SHP 0.832216
SLE 25.106926
SLL 23049.494848
SOS 628.455138
SRD 41.065249
STD 22751.039522
STN 24.508724
SVC 9.621819
SYP 14291.684943
SZL 18.940689
THB 37.260377
TJS 10.11532
TMT 3.847169
TND 3.332122
TOP 2.646589
TRY 55.472774
TTD 7.461995
TWD 36.212837
TZS 2923.832238
UAH 49.538761
UGX 4656.848203
USD 1.099191
UYU 44.637716
UZS 13174.228568
VES 1007.549417
VND 28309.670525
VUV 132.946216
WST 3.103326
XAF 655.957
XAG 0.024187
XAU 0.000296228459
XCD 2.97062
XCG 1.981896
XDR 0.777185
XOF 655.957
XPF 119.331742
YER 260.013433
ZAR 19.015684
ZMK 9894.042438
ZMW 22.599175
ZWL 353.939133
SSP 6462.804073
MXV 2.335721
  • CMSD

    -0.1200

    19.81

    -0.61%

  • JRI

    0.0000

    10.77

    0%

  • BCC

    -1.8200

    74.15

    -2.45%

  • CMSC

    -0.2228

    19.53

    -1.14%

  • BCE

    0.2000

    20.34

    +0.98%

  • RIO

    0.0100

    94.17

    +0.01%

  • AZN

    -2.7400

    161.47

    -1.7%

  • GSK

    -1.1800

    48.17

    -2.45%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    65

    0%

  • NGG

    0.8800

    75.82

    +1.16%

  • RYCEF

    -0.7300

    19.08

    -3.83%

  • BTI

    -0.4500

    54.4

    -0.83%

  • BP

    0.4700

    43.99

    +1.07%

  • RELX

    -0.0600

    33.18

    -0.18%

  • VOD

    -0.1800

    16.15

    -1.11%

Tata turmoil shines light on India succession woes
Tata turmoil shines light on India succession woes / Photo: INDRANIL MUKHERJEE - AFP/File

Tata turmoil shines light on India succession woes

In little over a month, the chairman of India's corporate giant Tata Group has gone from seeking another term to announcing his departure to returning to the role.

Text size:

The saga around N. Chandrasekaran, who has headed the multi-billion-dollar empire for nearly a decade, has laid bare the succession challenge confronting India's industrial behemoths.

The leadership battle at Tata Group, whose businesses span everything from Jaguar Land Rover cars to Apple iPhone assembly, has highlighted weaknesses in governance and the power struggle between boards and controlling families.

But the consequences extend far beyond shareholders, with a growing number of succession dramas shaking global confidence in India, whose economy relies heavily on corporate giants, analysts say.

The Tata fiasco came to a head last week when the board of Tata Sons, the group's holding company, granted Chandrasekaran another five-year term.

The announcement came despite objections from the Tata Trusts, the philanthropic entities that control the conglomerate and which is chaired by family patriarch Noel Tata.

"The mutiny of the board against the controlling shareholder is possibly a first, and not the right precedent for corporate India," independent advisory firm IiAS said in a note.

Tata is far from an isolated case: from banks to consumer goods, some of India's biggest companies have been rocked by leadership exits and botched handovers in recent months.

"In the last 18-24 months, we've seen a number of CEOs being churned at the top," Navnit Singh of executive search firm Korn Ferry told AFP.

"I do think boards may not be spending enough time looking at long-term succession. Often enough companies do not have a 'hit by the bus' contingent plan and are often caught off guard."

The roots of the Tata conflict run deep.

For much of the year, Chandrasekaran's future hung in the balance as Noel Tata raised concerns about losses at some group companies, investment spending and the possibility of listing Tata Sons.

- Leadership crisis -

The tensions intensified after the death of former patriarch Ratan Tata in 2024, leaving unresolved questions over how authority would be shared within India's largest conglomerate.

"When Ratan was alive, he didn't trust Noel Tata enough to make him the chairman of the Trusts," said Shriram Subramanian of advisory firm InGovern.

"He didn't ensure that there was a structured handover of power even when he was alive."

A succession crisis has also rocked India's largest private lender, HDFC Bank.

The bank's chief executive Sashidhar Jagdishan declined another term last month, an abrupt departure that came after the shock resignation of its chairman, forcing directors into a hurried search for new leadership.

At Godrej Consumer Products, chief executive Sudhir Sitapati secured shareholder approval for a second five-year term in August only to resign days later, fuelling speculation about tensions between management and the founding Godrej family.

Experts say such episodes reveal a failure by boards to prepare for leadership transitions before they become crises.

"Independent directors are meant to ask the uncomfortable question, 'who's next, and are they ready?' years before it becomes urgent," said Tulsi Jayakumar, an economics professor specialising in family business.

"Instead, most boards wait for a health scare or a boardroom crisis to even put succession on the agenda. That's not governance, that's crisis management wearing a governance hat."

- Ageing billionaires -

The Tata Group's annual revenues are roughly equivalent to about five percent of India's GDP, and it has become a key investor in strategic sectors including semiconductors, batteries and electronics manufacturing.

"When succession stumbles at a group the size of Tata, it isn't a private family matter, it's a systemic one," Jayakumar said.

Such conglomerates sit at the centre of supply chains, employ hundreds of thousands of people and play an outsized role in shaping investor confidence, she noted.

"A prolonged succession fight signals to global capital that governance in India still runs on personality, not process," she said.

The issue is particularly significant in a country where family-controlled businesses account for most economic activity.

India's ageing billionaires are preparing for one of the biggest intergenerational transfers of wealth globally to their children -- $382 billion according to UBS data -- which implies a massive shake-up in the way many of these empires will be run.

That transition could reshape some of the country's biggest corporate empires and test whether boards are prepared to manage increasingly complex successions.

"Succession planning is under far greater public scrutiny now," said Amit Tandon of IiAS, noting that investors understand that "when the baton is passed to the next generation... it changes the trajectory of the company".

"The best way to look at it is that succession planning is an art, not a science," he added.

"And Indian businesses haven't really cracked it yet."

(T.Burkhard--BBZ)