Berliner Boersenzeitung - Ukraine Loses Kursk: A Collapse?

EUR -
AED 4.263418
AFN 80.102537
ALL 97.805681
AMD 445.92619
ANG 2.077667
AOA 1064.548062
ARS 1462.724764
AUD 1.78108
AWG 2.089625
AZN 1.970327
BAM 1.944607
BBD 2.345598
BDT 141.147534
BGN 1.956957
BHD 0.437671
BIF 3296.963587
BMD 1.160903
BND 1.488333
BOB 8.027791
BRL 6.449741
BSD 1.161713
BTN 99.666306
BWP 15.621083
BYN 3.801816
BYR 22753.692361
BZD 2.333468
CAD 1.592468
CDF 3350.365078
CHF 0.930493
CLF 0.029264
CLP 1122.987363
CNY 8.327139
CNH 8.339333
COP 4684.822731
CRC 585.927315
CUC 1.160903
CUP 30.763921
CVE 110.924556
CZK 24.670688
DJF 206.315482
DKK 7.464557
DOP 69.985049
DZD 151.058119
EGP 57.359856
ERN 17.41354
ETB 158.521228
FJD 2.646274
FKP 0.864129
GBP 0.866857
GEL 3.145847
GGP 0.864129
GHS 12.072602
GIP 0.864129
GMD 83.004803
GNF 10048.773236
GTQ 8.91568
GYD 242.949454
HKD 9.112744
HNL 30.589896
HRK 7.535649
HTG 152.532003
HUF 400.499527
IDR 18889.743909
ILS 3.905579
IMP 0.864129
INR 99.830142
IQD 1520.7825
IRR 48903.025148
ISK 142.419701
JEP 0.864129
JMD 185.651363
JOD 0.823043
JPY 172.712714
KES 150.339252
KGS 101.516991
KHR 4666.828971
KMF 492.948309
KPW 1044.839818
KRW 1610.334071
KWD 0.355118
KYD 0.968127
KZT 610.98309
LAK 25034.866299
LBP 103958.834524
LKR 349.756748
LRD 233.341266
LSL 20.814798
LTL 3.427844
LVL 0.702218
LYD 6.280324
MAD 10.519518
MDL 19.63299
MGA 5142.798473
MKD 61.604186
MMK 2437.527181
MNT 4161.658823
MOP 9.393231
MRU 46.110683
MUR 52.751702
MVR 17.871696
MWK 2015.92058
MXN 21.834054
MYR 4.939678
MZN 74.250898
NAD 20.815169
NGN 1775.66964
NIO 42.663115
NOK 11.895108
NPR 159.466089
NZD 1.948951
OMR 0.446358
PAB 1.161713
PEN 4.134022
PGK 4.798301
PHP 65.979972
PKR 330.451204
PLN 4.264226
PYG 8995.222163
QAR 4.226384
RON 5.07837
RSD 117.150452
RUB 90.639837
RWF 1667.636688
SAR 4.354117
SBD 9.658199
SCR 16.891204
SDG 697.121269
SEK 11.283068
SGD 1.491731
SHP 0.912287
SLE 26.062511
SLL 24343.553151
SOS 663.454797
SRD 43.492635
STD 24028.341446
SVC 10.164492
SYP 15093.882638
SZL 20.814972
THB 37.822193
TJS 11.105873
TMT 4.074768
TND 3.367202
TOP 2.718952
TRY 46.735626
TTD 7.886604
TWD 34.134141
TZS 3032.862341
UAH 48.579867
UGX 4164.031217
USD 1.160903
UYU 47.347461
UZS 14853.749195
VES 134.316236
VND 30343.093576
VUV 138.731534
WST 3.18577
XAF 652.202823
XAG 0.030725
XAU 0.000349
XCD 3.137398
XDR 0.811419
XOF 652.427167
XPF 119.331742
YER 280.183787
ZAR 20.804902
ZMK 10449.515398
ZMW 26.515374
ZWL 373.810187
  • CMSC

    0.0900

    22.314

    +0.4%

  • CMSD

    0.0250

    22.285

    +0.11%

  • RBGPF

    0.0000

    69.04

    0%

  • SCS

    0.0400

    10.74

    +0.37%

  • RELX

    0.0300

    53

    +0.06%

  • RIO

    -0.1400

    59.33

    -0.24%

  • GSK

    0.1300

    41.45

    +0.31%

  • NGG

    0.2700

    71.48

    +0.38%

  • BP

    0.1750

    30.4

    +0.58%

  • BTI

    0.7150

    48.215

    +1.48%

  • BCC

    0.7900

    91.02

    +0.87%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    13.13

    +0.15%

  • VOD

    0.0100

    9.85

    +0.1%

  • BCE

    -0.0600

    22.445

    -0.27%

  • RYCEF

    0.1000

    12

    +0.83%

  • AZN

    -0.1200

    73.71

    -0.16%


Ukraine Loses Kursk: A Collapse?




Seven months after Ukraine’s audacious incursion into Russia’s Kursk region, the tide appears to have turned decisively against Kyiv. Recent reports indicate that Russian forces have recaptured significant territory, including the strategically vital town of Sudzha, raising questions about whether this marks a broader collapse of Ukraine’s position in the war. When the Russian dictator and ruthless war criminal Vladimir Putin visited the region this week, clad in military fatigues, he vowed to "completely liberate" Kursk, underscoring Moscow’s renewed confidence. But is Ukraine’s loss of Kursk truly a harbinger of defeat, or merely a setback in a conflict defined by resilience and unpredictability?

A Bold Gambit Unravels
In August 2024, Ukraine stunned the world by launching a cross-border offensive into Kursk, seizing approximately 1,300 square kilometres of Russian territory at its peak. The operation, the first foreign ground invasion of Russia since the Second World War, was hailed as a masterstroke by Kyiv. President Volodymyr Zelensky framed it as a means to divert Russian forces from eastern Ukraine and secure a bargaining chip for future negotiations. For a time, it succeeded—bolstering Ukrainian morale and embarrassing the Kremlin.

Yet, the initial triumph has given way to a grim reality. Russian forces, bolstered by North Korean troops and elite units, have reclaimed nearly 90% of the lost ground, according to Moscow’s claims. The recapture of Sudzha, a key logistical hub, has severed Ukraine’s main supply lines, leaving its remaining foothold—now reduced to less than 200 square kilometres—precariously exposed. Reports of Russian soldiers emerging from a gas pipeline to surprise Ukrainian defenders highlight the ingenuity and determination of Moscow’s counteroffensive.

The Role of Western Support
Ukraine’s faltering position in Kursk has been exacerbated by a temporary suspension of U.S. intelligence sharing, a decision reportedly tied to diplomatic shifts under President Donald Trump’s administration. Ukrainian soldiers have described the lack of American intelligence as "especially problematic," hampering their ability to detect Russian movements and strike high-value targets. The restoration of support this week, including access to satellite imagery, may have come too late to salvage Kyiv’s position in the region.

Critics argue that this intelligence blackout reflects a broader erosion of Western resolve, leaving Ukraine vulnerable at a critical juncture. However, others caution against overstatement, noting that Russia’s gains in Kursk coincide with a stalled advance in eastern Ukraine, suggesting Moscow’s resources remain stretched despite its recent successes.

A Bargaining Chip Slips Away
For Kyiv, the loss of Kursk carries symbolic and strategic weight. Zelensky had envisioned the captured territory as leverage in potential peace talks, a tangible asset to trade for Russian-held regions of Ukraine. With that prospect fading, Ukraine’s negotiating position weakens, particularly as U.S. officials prepare to discuss a 30-day ceasefire proposal with Moscow. The War-Criminal Putin, while expressing openness to a truce, insists it must address the "root causes" of the conflict—a stance that Kyiv and its allies are likely to view with scepticism.

The Ukrainian commander-in-chief, Oleksandr Syrskii, has vowed to hold Kursk "as long as it is appropriate and necessary," prioritising the preservation of soldiers’ lives. Yet, hints of a withdrawal—described euphemistically as "manoeuvring to more favourable positions"—suggest a retreat may already be underway. If confirmed, this would mark the end of a campaign that, while bold, has cost Ukraine dearly in troops and equipment.

Collapse or Strategic Recalibration?
Does the loss of Kursk signal Ukraine’s collapse? Not necessarily. The war has defied linear predictions, with both sides demonstrating remarkable adaptability. Ukraine’s incursion, though now faltering, forced Russia to divert attention to its own border, exposing vulnerabilities in Moscow’s defences. Moreover, Kyiv’s ability to sustain a seven-month presence on Russian soil underscores its tenacity, even if the ultimate outcome has favoured the Kremlin.

Nevertheless, the setback is undeniable. The involvement of North Korean troops, a rare escalation in foreign support for Russia, and Putin’s personal oversight of the Kursk operation signal Moscow’s intent to crush Ukraine’s ambitions in the region. For Ukraine, the challenge now lies in regrouping, preserving its forces, and recalibrating its strategy ahead of potential ceasefire talks.

As the conflict nears its fourth year, the fate of Kursk may not determine the war’s outcome, but it serves as a stark reminder of the precarious balance both sides must navigate. Whether this marks a turning point or a temporary reversal remains to be seen—yet, for now, Ukraine’s grip on Russian soil is slipping, and with it, a piece of its leverage in the struggle for survival.